Abstract
In recent work, we discovered that the presence of highly substoichiometric amounts (10-8 molar ratio) of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) from Gram-negative bacteria caused fibrinogen clotting to lead to the formation of an amyloid form of fibrin. We here show that the broadly equivalent lipoteichoic acids (LTAs) from two species of Gram-positive bacteria have similarly (if not more) potent effects. Using thioflavin T fluorescence to detect amyloid as before, the addition of low concentrations of free ferric ion is found to have similar effects. Luminescent conjugated oligothiophene dyes (LCOs), marketed under the trade name AmytrackerTM, also stain classical amyloid structures. We here show that they too give very large fluorescence enhancements when clotting is initiated in the presence of the four amyloidogens (LPS, ferric ions and two LTA types). The staining patterns differ significantly as a function of both the amyloidogens and the dyes used to assess them, indicating clearly that the nature of the clots formed is different. This is also the case when clotting is measured viscometrically using thermoelastography. Overall, the data provide further evidence for an important role of bacterial cell wall products in the various coagulopathies that are observable in chronic, inflammatory diseases. The assays may have potential in both diagnostics and therapeutics.
Introduction
In recent work, we have developed the idea that lipopolysaccharides (LPS) from the Gram-negative cell envelope can be shed from dormant bacteria or from continual bacteria entry into the blood e.g. via a leaky gut, and serve to contribute to the chronic inflammation characteristic of a considerable number of diseases [1–6]. Coupled to iron dysregulation [7], this leads to various coagulopathies [8] and changes in the morphology [9] both of erythrocytes and of the fibrin formed following blood clotting. A particularly striking finding was the fact that this ‘anomalous’ fibrin (sometimes referred to by us as ‘dense matter deposits’ (DMDs), e.g. [10, 11]) could be induced by tiny amounts of LPS amounting to 1 LPS molecule per 108 molecules of fibrinogen [12]. This kind of sub-stoichiometric or autocatalytic activity was reminiscent of prion-like or β-amyloid behaviour. Indeed the ‘anomalous’ fibrin was found to be stainable by the amyloid-selective stain Thioflavin T (ThT), and hence amyloid in nature [12]. This provided a straightforward explanation for a number of elements of its biology, not least its resistance to degradation by the usual enzymes [8, 11].
This narrative could account for the role of Gram-negative bacteria, but not for that of Gram-positives, as these do not possess LPS. By contrast, their cell walls contain lipoteichoic acids (LTA), soluble peptidoglycan and muropeptides. There is a general feeling [13], especially since LTA has been properly purified [14], that LTA is just as capable as is LPS of providing an inflammatory stimulus to cells. While LPS mainly interacts with toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) [2, 15–17], LTA stimulates target cells mainly by activating toll-like receptor 2 [13, 18–28], and with the glycolipid anchor of LTA playing a central role, analogous to the lipid A of LPS [29]. This is reasonable, as from the host’s point of a view an invading microorganism is simply undesirable, whatever its reaction to the Gram stain. Indeed, modulo a few detailed differences [30], and certainly for our present purposes, it seems that LTA is indeed broadly equivalent to LPS in terms of its ability to stimulate an innate immune response [31–33].
As well as the well-known ThT (e.g. [11, 34–50]), a considerable number of other fluorogenic stains have been shown to illuminate amyloids (e.g. [11, 51–67]). In particular, Nilsson and colleagues have developed a number of novel fluorescent amyloidogenic markers. Some of these are referred to as luminescent conjugated oligothiophenes (LCOs) [68–76] and are marketed as Amytracker™ 480 and 680 (also known as HS163 and hFTAA in the literature [71, 74]); (see Figure 1 for the chemical structures of Amytracker™ 480 and 680). Although they too show strong selectivity for, and enhanced fluorescence when binding to, classical amyloid proteins, their staining properties clearly differ from those of ThT [68, 70, 77–79]. In some cases, their binding affects prion formation itself [80, 81] (and even ThT has anti-ageing properties at low concentrations [82]). It was thus of interest to assess these too as amyloid markers of the fibrin(ogen) blood clotting system.
The question then arose as to whether LTA and unliganded iron (which is also almost always dysregulated during inflammation [7, 85, 86]), could display just as strong an ability to divert fibrinogen polymerisation from the normal to the amyloid form as could LPS. This was very much the case, and the present study shows the amyloid-forming nature of blood clots formed in plasma in the presence of low concentrations of iron, LPS from E. coli, and two LTAs from Staphylococcus aureus and Streptococcus pyogenes. These latter were chosen on the basis of coming from infectious, Gram-positive organisms. A preprint has been lodged at bioRxiv.
Materials and Methods
Ethical statement
This study was approved by the Ethical Committee of the University of Pretoria (South Africa) and Stellenbosch University: ethics clearance number: 298/2016. We adhered strictly to the Declaration of Helsinki. A written form of informed consent was obtained from all healthy donors (available on request). Blood was collected and methods were carried out in accordance with the relevant guidelines of the ethics committee.
Sample population
40 healthy individuals were included in the study. Exclusion criteria for the healthy population were: known (chronic and acute) inflammatory conditions such as asthma, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) or tuberculosis; risk factors associated with metabolic syndrome; smoking; and, if female, being on contraceptive or hormone replacement treatment. This population did not take any anti-inflammatory medication. Whole blood (WB) of the participants was obtained in citrate tubes. WB was used for thromboelastography (TEG) [8, 87]. and platelet poor plasma (PPP) was used for confocal and super-resolution analysis.
Iron, LPS, LTA1 and LTA2
The following concentrations of the various amyloid-inducing substances were used:
A final exposure iron concentration (FeCl3, MW 270.32) of 5 μM was used in all experiments
The LPS used was from E. coli O111:B4 (Sigma, L2630). A final LPS exposure concentration of 0.4 ng.L-1 was used.
LTA1 was from Staphylococcus aureus (Sigma, L2515) and a final LTA1 exposure concentration of 1 ng.L-1 was used in all experiments.
LTA2 was from Streptococcus pyogenes (Sigma, L3140) and a final LTA1 exposure concentration of 1 ng.L-1 was used in all experiments.
Confocal microscopy
Platelet poor plasma (PPP) was prepared by centrifuging WB for 15 minutes at 3000 x g, followed by storage at −80°C. We incubated the four candidate amyloidogenic molecules for one hour before adding fluorescent markers. On the day of analysis, all −80°C-stored PPPs were brought to room temperature and incubated for one hour with either LPS, iron, LTA1 or LTA2 (final concentrations given in previous section). This pre-incubation was followed by an incubation of 30 minutes with ThT at a final concentration of 5 μM and Amytracker™ 480 and 680 (0.1 μL into 100 μL PPP). Naïve PPP was incubated only with the 3 markers. Before viewing clots on the confocal microscope, thrombin was added in the ratio 1:2, (5 μL thrombin: 10 μL PPP) and extensive fibrin networks, created. Thrombin was provided by the South African National Blood Service, and the thrombin solution was at a concentration of 20 U/ml and made up in a biological buffer containing 0.2% human serum albumin. A coverslip was placed over the prepared clot, and samples were viewed using a Zeiss LSM 510 META confocal microscope with a Plan-Apochromat 63x/1.4 Oil DIC objective. For ThT, the excitation laser used was 488 nm and emission measured at 508 to 570 nm, for Amytracker™ 480 the 405 nm laser was used with emission measured at 478 to 539 nm, and for Amytracker ™ 680 the 561 nm laser was used for excitation with emission measured at 597 to 695 nm. A selection of micrographs of the prepared clots with and without the four molecules was captured. Gain settings were kept the same during all data capture and used for statistical analyses; however, brightness and contrast were slightly adjusted for figure preparation. We also prepared Z-stacks of clots where the candidate amyloidogenic molecules (iron, LPS, LTA1 and LTA2) were added to PPP.
Thromboelastography
Clot property studies
Whole blood (WB) was incubated for 24 hours at room temperature with either iron, LPS, LTA1 or LTA2, or left untreated (naïve sample). Clot property studies using thromboelastography (TEG) were performed as follows: 340μL of naïve or treated WB were placed in a TEG cup and 20μl of 0.2M CaCl2 was added. CaCl2 is necessary to reverse the effect of the collecting tube’s sodium citrate and consequently initiate coagulation. The samples were then placed in a Thromboelastograph 5000 Hemostasis Analyzer System for analysis. Seven parameters, as shown in Table 1, were studied [87–89].
Statistical analysis
TEG results were analysed using the STATSDIRECT (version 2.8.0) software using the paired t-test; notwithstanding its arbitrary nature [90–92], significance was taken as P ≤ 0.05. Confocal techniques are usually used only as qualitative methods. We captured the fluorescent signal of each of the three fluorescent markers as a composite.czi file in the Zeiss ZEN software and then used ImageJ (FIJI) to split the channels. Then we assessed the variance between (black) background and the presence of fluorescent pixels (binary comparison) for each of the three fluorescent markers in clots. For this, we used the histogram function in ImageJ(FIJI) and calculated the coefficient of variation (CV) (as SD/mean) as our metric to quantify and discriminate between clots of healthy naïve PPP and clots with the candidate amyloidogenic molecules. Sample analysis was performed with the Mann-Whitney U test, using the STATSDIRECT (version 2.8.0) software.
Raw data storage
Raw data are stored on Onedrive that is an open access storage database: (https://1drv.ms/f/s!AgoCOmY3bkKHrx0mNYcZwf2i3Ow6) and on the first corresponding author’s researchgate profile, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Etheresia_Pretorius, as raw data.
RESULTS
Confocal microscopy
Confocal analysis of healthy clotted naïve PPP, in the presence of ThT, Amytracker™ 480 and 680, showed occasional small patches of fluorescence (see Figure 2A to C). However, when any of the four candidate amyloidogenic molecules were pre-incubated with healthy PPP prior to addition of thrombin, the fluorescence in all three channels was greatly enhanced. This suggests increased binding of ThT, as well as of the two Amytracker markers. Amytracker binding, in particular, is a confirmation that amyloidogenesis is promoted by exposure to the four molecules. Amyloidogenesis was most prominent in PPP exposed to the 2 LTAs, suggesting that there are increased β-sheet-rich amyloid areas in the LTA-exposed fibrin(ogen) (Figure 2J to O). Previously, we concluded that LPS binding causes the fibrinogen to polymerise into a form with a greatly increased amount of ß-sheet (in the presence of thrombin), reflecting amyloid formation [12]. This results in a strong fluorescence observable (when excited ca 440 nm) in the presence of ThT (see e.g. [11, 35, 36, 49, 93]). Here we confirm that the LPS, iron and the 2 LTAs not only result in ThT binding, plausibly to open hydrophobic areas on fibrin, but that lipoteichoic acids can indeed initiate amyloidogenesis of fibrin(ogen) (as confirmed by the Amytracker ™ 480 and 680 binding). The analysis of the micrographs suggest that the Amytracker ™480 and 680 and the ThT do not bind at identical molecular sites on the fibrin, but that they bind in the same molecular vicinity. We therefore suggest that ThT and Amytracker ™ binding do not interfere with each other. Figure 3A to D also show separate and composite z-stack figures of healthy PPP exposed to the 4 different molecules. These results suggest that the Amytrackers™ mainly bind on different parts of the proteins, and that their binding pattern differs between the amyloid formed in the presence of the four different amyloidogenic molecules. Videos of the z-stacks are stored with raw data on OneDrive (see supplementary information). Statistical (coefficient of variation, CV) data are plotted in Figure 4. Data from the three different markers of each of the four amyloidogenic molecules all differed significantly from that of the controls (P < 0.0001). CV analyses were done on over 1750 micrographs.
Thromboelastography
Table 2 shows demographic data of the sample (used for confocal and TEG analysis) and the TEG results of the naïve WB, as well as the results after 24-hour exposure with the 4 different molecules. There is a significantly decreased R-value in the presence of LPS, suggesting that the LPS causes WB to clot faster [87]. This was also previously demonstrated with a lower LPS concentration.
Iron results show significant P-values for R, K, angle and TMRTG values, suggesting that the clot forms faster, the clot reaches its (20 mm) set point more slowly, there is more crosslinking of fibrin fibres and there is a decreased time from clot initiation to maximum clot formation. Considering that iron affects more TEG parameters than does LPS, free iron therefore has a more profound effect on clot formation than does LPS at the concentrations used, causing whole blood to be more hypercoagulable [8]. When LTA2 was used, only the MA parameter (maximal amplitude measured in mm) of LTA2 was significantly different from the naïve MA. Overall, the TEG results provide further evidence that the type of amyloid formed differs between LPS, iron, LTA1 and LTA2 when they are used as inducers
DISCUSSION
In previous work [11, 12], as part of a systems biology approach to understanding the dormant bacterial basis and aetiology of coagulopathies accompanying various inflammatory diseases (e.g. [2, 4, 5, 9, 94–96]), we demonstrated that exceptionally low (and highly substoichiometric) concentrations of LPS could induce the formation of an amyloid form of fibrin. A chief piece of evidence was the extensive fluorescence staining when ThT was added. This was an entirely novel and unexpected finding, although Strickland and colleagues have shown that fibrin(ogen) can interact with known β-amyloid-forming peptides and proteins (e.g. [97–102]).
LPS is a component of Gram-negative bacteria, so an obvious question arose as to whether or not the equivalent molecules in Gram-positive organisms (especially lipoteichoic acid) would have similar effects. In addition, we wished to take the opportunity to assess the utility of various novel conjugated oligothiophene amyloid stains, now commercially available as the ‘Amytracker’™ series, to illuminate amyloids.
In the present paper, we show that LPS, iron, and the 2 LTAs cause amyloid formation of plasma proteins, and in particular of fibrin(ogen) as blood is clotted. We confirmed amyloidogenesis by using small ligands identifying amyloid protein deposits [72]. Specifically, we used Amytracker™ 480 (HS163) and 680 (hFTAA) which are fluorescent amyloid ligands, also termed luminescent conjugated oligothiophenes (LCOs) [72, 84]. These two fluorescent markers bind rapidly and with high sensitivity to detect protein amyloid formation in fibrin(ogen). Previously we showed that ThT binds to areas of amyloidogenic fibrin(ogen) that are created by LPS exposure during clotting. Here we confirm that observation using LPS, and show further that iron and the 2 LTAs all cause changes in fibrin(ogen) conformation to an amyloid(ogenic) nature.
It is known that the Amytracker™ dyes are spectrally richer, can discriminate different forms of amyloid, and that their staining properties clearly differ from those of ThT [68, 70, 77–79]. Comparison (e.g. Figure 2) of the staining with the three dyes (ThT and Amytracker™ 480 and 680) in the presence of the four candidate amyloidogenic molecules showed that this is also true for the amyloid form(s) of fibrin induced by the different agents. These clearly different staining patterns occur for each dye, with those of the two Amytracker™ dyes showing greater staining and being more similar (but not identical) to each other.
This becomes even clearer when we observe the staining in the z-stack projections (Figure 3 and supplementary video information of the clots shown in Figure 3), with the Amytracker™ 480 seeming to favour the larger fibres characteristic of LTA2. These differences were also observed in the TEG traces: while iron changed four of the TEG variables significantly (R, K, angle and TMRTG), LPS showed a significantly increased R-value, LTA1 was without effect, while LTA2 affected only the MA (and that marginally).
We conclude that lipoteichoic acids are even more potent and effective than is LPS in binding to fibrinogen and in affecting the manner in which it self-organises during blood clotting. Such findings have profound significance for our understanding of the aetiology of anomalous blood clots, and may have value in diagnosis, prognosis and treatment of chronic, inflammatory diseases.
DECLARATION OF AUTHORSHIP
EP: co-project leader, confocal and statistical analysis; MJP: figure analysis and rendering, technical preparation of all samples; TEG analysis; SRB, NBN, LH: technical assistance; DBK: co-project leader and originator of suggestion of using LTAs.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (grant BB/L025752/1), as well as the National Research Foundation (NRF) and Medical Research Council (MRC) of South Africa for supporting this collaboration.
Footnotes
1 Paper 13 in the series “a dormant blood microbiome in chronic, inflammatory diseases”
REFERENCES
- [1].↵
- [2].↵
- [3].↵
- [4].↵
- [5].↵
- [6].↵
- [7].↵
- [8].↵
- [9].↵
- [10].↵
- [11].↵
- [12].↵
- [13].↵
- [14].↵
- [15].↵
- [16].↵
- [17].↵
- [18].↵
- [19].↵
- [20].↵
- [21].↵
- [22].↵
- [23].↵
- [24].↵
- [25].↵
- [26].↵
- [27].↵
- [28].↵
- [29].↵
- [30].↵
- [31].↵
- [32].↵
- [33].↵
- [34].↵
- [35].↵
- [36].↵
- [37].↵
- [38].↵
- [39].↵
- [40].↵
- [41].↵
- [42].↵
- [43].↵
- [44].↵
- [45].↵
- [46].↵
- [47].↵
- [48].↵
- [49].↵
- [50].↵
- [51].↵
- [52].↵
- [53].↵
- [54].↵
- [55].↵
- [56].↵
- [57].↵
- [58].↵
- [59].↵
- [60].↵
- [61].↵
- [62].↵
- [63].↵
- [64].↵
- [65].↵
- [66].↵
- [67].↵
- [68].↵
- [69].↵
- [70].↵
- [71].↵
- [72].↵
- [73].↵
- [74].↵
- [75].↵
- [76].↵
- [77].↵
- [78].↵
- [79].↵
- [80].↵
- [81].↵
- [82].↵
- [83].↵
- [84].↵
- [85].↵
- [86].↵
- [87].↵
- [88].↵
- [89].↵
- [90].↵
- [91].↵
- [92].↵
- [93].↵
- [94].↵
- [95].↵
- [96].↵
- [97].↵
- [98].↵
- [99].↵
- [100].↵
- [101].↵
- [102].↵