Evolution in Sinocyclocheilus cavefish is marked by rate shifts, reversals and origin of novel traits

ABSTRACT

Epitomized by the well-studied Astyanax mexicanus, cavefishes provide important model organisms to understand adaptations in response to divergent natural selection. However, the spectacular Sinocyclocheilus diversification of China, the most diverse cavefish clade in the world harboring nearly 75 species, demonstrate evolutionary convergence for many traits, yet remain poorly understood in terms of their morphological evolution. Here, using a broad sample of 49 species representative of this diversification, we analyze patterns of Sinocylocheilus evolution in a phylogenetic context. We categorized species into morphs based on eye-related condition: Blind, Micro-eyed (small-eyed), and Normal-eyed and we also considered three habitat types (Troglodytic – cave-restricted; Troglophilic – cave-associated; Surface – outside of caves). Geometric morphometric analyses show Normal-eyed morphs with fusiform shapes being segregated from Blind/Micro-eyed (Eye-regressed) morphs with deeper bodies along the first principal component (“PC”) axis. The second PC axis accounts for shape complexity related to the presence of horns. Ancestral character reconstructions of morphs suggest at least three independent origins of Blind morphs, each with different levels of modification in relation to the typical morphology of ancestral Normal-eyed morphs. Interestingly, only some Blind or Micro-eyed morphs bear horns and they are restricted to a single clade (Clade B) and arising from a Troglodytic ancestral species. Our geophylogeny shows an east-to-west diversification spanning the Pliocene and the Pleistocene, with Troglodytic species dominating karstic subterranean habitats of the plains whereas predominantly Surface species inhabit streams and pools in hills to the west (perhaps due to the scarcity of caves). Integration of morphology, phylogeny and geography suggests Sinocyclocheilus are pre-adapted for cave dwelling. Analyses of evolutionary rates suggest that lineages leading to Blind morphs were characterized by significant rate shifts, such as a slowdown in body size evolution and a 3.3 to 12.5 fold increase in the evolutionary rate of eye regression. Furthermore, body size and eye size have undergone reversals, but horns have not, a trait that seem to require substantial evolutionary time to form. These results, compared to the Astyanax model system, indicate Sinocyclocheilus fishes demonstrate extraordinary morphological diversity and variation, offering an invaluable model system to explore evolutionary novelty.