ABSTRACT
Vaginal dryness is a common symptom associated with vulvovaginal atrophy of menopause. The impact of vaginal dryness is very significant as it negatively affects quality of life, daily activities, sexual satisfaction as well as on interpersonal relationships. Symptoms of vaginal dryness is often underreported and undertreated. Recently, vaginal lubricants and moisturizers have been applied as one of the alternative and safe approaches to relieve vaginal dryness for women with mild to moderate vaginal dryness. We evaluated the safety and beneficial effects of a new type of estrogen-free vaginal gel, Feminilove BIO-FRESH moisturizing vaginal gel, using in vitro and in vivo experimental tools. Our results suggest that; 1) Feminilove vaginal gel exhibits minimal cell cytotoxicity on various human vaginal cells; 2) Feminilove vaginal gel exhibits minimal side-effects on the structure of vaginal mucosa stratum of experimental animals; 3) Feminiove vaginal gel inhibits the growth of pathogenic vaginal bacteria (E. coli) while promotes the growth of beneficial vaginal bacteria (Lactobacillus spp); 4) Feminilove vaginal gel elicits an anti-inflammatory response on vaginal epithelial cells; and 5) Feminilove vaginal gel promotes the production of tropoelastin and collagen on cultural vaginal smooth muscle and may restore loose vaginal wall (i.e., tightening effects). In summary, our results indicate that Feminilove BIO-FRESH moisturizing vaginal gel is a safe and effective remedy for vaginal dryness and vulvovaginal atrophy in women.
I. INTRODUCTION
Vaginal dryness is common condition in women during and after menopause.1–4 Symptoms pf vaginal dryness has been associated with vaginal or vulvovaginal atrophy (VVA). 5,6 Prevalence of vaginal dryness due to VVA ranges from 15% to as high as 57% among postmenopausal women.3 A lack of natural vaginal lubrication during intercourse is an unpleasant experience for both sexual partners. As part of the cultural norms, men prefer and expect their female sexual partners to secrete vaginal lubrication during intercourse.7 In addition, sexually active women prefer to maintain and achieve proper vaginal lubrication during intercourse to enjoy the sexual activity as well as interpersonal intimacy.8,9 The underlying culprits for diminished vaginal lubrication may include hormonal changes due to menopause, stress, vaginal inflammation, chronic illnesses such as diabetes and chronic kidney disease, and medical treatment related side effects such as anti-depressants, chemotherapy and radiation.9–11 Vaginal dryness will likely lead to painful intercourse which has affected more than half of sexually active women at some point in their lives.12–14 Vaginal dryness and VVA has affected more than half of women during and after menopause.15,16 Recent survey in the US showed that vaginal dryness could also occur in younger women due to the utilization of antiestrogen medications.17 Symptoms of vaginal dryness and VVA are progressive and a variety of treatments include vaginal estrogen medication and different over the counter regimens such as vaginal moisturizers and lubricants.18,19 Recent data suggest that vaginal moisturizers and lubricants provide fast relief for vaginal dryness and dyspareunia and may attenuate discomfort for painful intercourse.20–22 Feminilove BIO-FRESH moisturizing vaginal gel, a new type of estrogen-free vaginal gel, was manufactured and distributed by Epoch NE Corporation, Seattle, WA, USA and Certified to NSF/ANSI 305 by Oregon Tilth. In this study, we aim to investigate the safety and efficacy of Feminilove vaginal gel for the treatment of symptoms associated with vaginal dryness and VVA by employing both in vitro and in vivo experimental models.
II. METHODS
1. Cell viability test
We used the Cell Titer-Glo 2.0 Assay to assess cell viability.23 Actual procedures were according to the manufacturer’s guideline. We test the viability of 3 most popular vaginal gel products from Amazon (Vmagic Organic Vulva Cream vaginal moisturizer, Vulvacare vaginal moisturizer & intimate skin cream, Membrasin Topical Vulua Cream for Feminine Dryness) as well as Feminilove vaginal gel on 3 human cell lines (vaginal epithelial cell, cervical epithelial and endometrial epithelial cell). The detailed components for each product are listed in Table 1.
2. Animals
Sexually mature female New Zealand white rabbits (6-month-old) were purchased from Charles River Laboratories. All rabbits were fed ad libitum with rabbit food pellets (Teklad 7015; Harlan Teklad). The acclimation is 4 weeks prior to the use in the intravaginal study. Procedures listed in this study were strictly followed guidelines of USDA Animal Welfare Act and Animal Welfare Regulations.
2.1 Rabbit vaginal irritation test
Female rabbits received 1 ml of placebo control gel or 1 ml of various Feminilove vaginal gel (0.01%, 0.1%, or 1.0%) via intravaginal administration for 10 consecutive days. The actual procedures for intravaginal instillation and insertion of the control gel or various contents of Feminilove vaginal gel were followed the published protocols.24,25
During the 10 days of study, we daily monitored the rabbits. On day 11, rabbits were sacrificed with injecting of ketamine and xylazine and serum from rabbits as well as vaginal tissues were extracted for subsequent investigation.
2.2 Rabbit vaginal tissue histology evaluation
Fixed vaginal tissues were embedded and stained, following standard hematoxylin and eosin procedures. Slides of the vaginal sections were examined under microscope. Sections of vaginal tissues were evaluated for vaginal irritation for the scale of scores. 1 = no irritation; 2 = mild irritation; 3 = moderate and 4 = severe irritation.24 The sign of vaginal irritation includes exfoliation, infiltration of leukocyte and edema of vaginal epithelial cells.
2.3 Cell proliferation
Rabbit vaginal sections were evaluated for cell proliferation (Zymed PCNA kit, Zymed Laboratories). Actual immunostaining Procedures were followed the manufacturer’s protocol. Stained vaginal sections observed under microscope and the scoring of a minimum of 600 cells was calculated.24,25
2.4 Parameters of serum and blood chemistry
Blood samples from rabbits were analyzed, following standard procedrues.25 The hematology parameters include red blood cell count, leukocyte count, concentration of hemoglobin and hematocrit, platelet, and platelet volume.
3. in vitro reconstituted vaginal epithelium model
Three-dimensional tissue composed of normal human ectocervico-vaginal epithelial cells grown on polycarbonate filters using specially formulated serum-free medium were obtained from SkinEthic Laboratories (Nice, France). When cultured in vitro on a polycarbonate filter at the air-liquid interface in a defined medium, these cells form a 3-dimensional epithelial tissue resembling human in vivo vaginal mucosa. This in vitro tissue reproduces many of the histological, ultrastructural, and protein expression properties of native tissue, including interdigitation of cells, glycogen production, and cytokeratin expression. Before treatment, the tissue cultures were pre-incubated at 37 ⍰C and 5% CO2 for 24 hours. Prior to dosing, the medium was aspirated and triplicate wells of 6-well plates containing the in vitro reconstituted human vaginal epithelial tissues (size 0.5 cm2) grown on polycarbonate membrane filters were treated with or without increasing concentrations of FeminiLove (0.01, 0.1, or 1.0%) in 1 ml of medium or applied topically via a gel formulation and incubated for an additional 24 hours. The parameter determined in vitro was the histoarchitecture of exposed epithelial cells. At the end of the treatments, vaginal tissue inserts were washed in phosphate-buffered saline, and the polycarbonate filters covered with the vaginal tissue were cut out, fixed in 10% buffered formalin, embedded in paraffin, sectioned to 4 μm, and stained with hematoxylin and eosin as described previously.
4. Epithelial cell culture and stimulation
We purchased 3 human epithelial cells lines (vaginal cell line VK2/E6E7, endocervical End/E6E7 and ectocervical Ect/E6E7) from ATCC for this study. All cell lines were maintained in serum free keratinocyte medium and supplements with 0.5 mg/ml bovine serum, 0.1 ng/ml recombinant human epithelial growth factor, 50 mg/ml streptomycin and 50 U/ml penicillin (Life Technologies). Cultured cells were seeded into 24-well tissue culture plates for 7 days. Epithelial monolayers were co-cultured with 0.3% Feminilove in the presence or absence of the lipopolysaccharide (1 mg/ml) for 18 hours. prior to subsequent cytokine analysis. The production of IL-1β, IL-6, and TNFα from stimulated epithelial cells was assessed on a Bio-Plex 200 Luminex reader.
5. Fastin elastin assay
Human vaginal smooth muscle cells were grown to the confluence in a 96-well culture plates with 10% FBS. Culture medium were pre-heated to 65 °C prior to placing into the culture plates. We collected cell lysates and supernatants and cell lysates 48 hours after the initiation of experiment. Fastin Elastin Assay kits (Biocolor Ltd, Carrickfergus, UK was used to assess the contents of elastin.
6. Sircol collagen assay
We assessed collagen content of the collagen using Sircol Assay Kits (Biocolor Ltd., Carrickfergus, UK). Actual procedures were according to the instructions of the manufacturer. Cells in 96-well plates with serum-free DMEM were co-cultured with various concentration of Feminilove vaginal gels. Cell lysates and supernatants were collected 48 hours after the initiation of experiment.
7. Statistical analysis
Statistical analyses were performed using GraphPad Prism version 9.1.1. All data are presented as mean ± S.E.M. For comparison of the means between two groups, data were analyzed by Student’s 2-tailed t test. Differences of the means for more than two groups containing two variables were analyzed using 2-way ANOVA. Post-hoc analysis was performed with Tukey’s test. A p value less than 0.05 was considered significant.
III. RESULTS
1. Minimal toxicity of vaginal gel products
Detailed information for 4 vaginal gel products (Vmagic Organic Vulva Cream vaginal moisturizer, Vulvacare vaginal moisturizer & intimate skin cream, Membrasin Topical Vulua Cream for Feminine Dryness and Feminilove BIO-FRESH moisturizing vaginal gel) are listed in Table 1.
Our results suggest that all four vaginal gel products exhibited a minimal toxicity on cultured human vaginal cells (Figure 1). More importantly, toxicity tolerance of Feminilove vaginal gel is similarly to those 3 most popular vaginal gel products available in Amazon (Vmagic Organic Vulva Cream vaginal moisturizer, Vulvacare vaginal moisturizer & intimate skin cream and Membrasin Topical Vulua Cream for Feminine Dryness).
2. Effect of Feminilove vaginal gel on the rabbit’s vaginal mucosa
Table 2 listed the results of histological morphology in the rabbit vaginal tissue after 10 days of intravaginal application of a gel formulation with or without 0.01, 0.1, or 1% Feminilove vaginal gel.
Figure 2 shows representative mid vaginal sections of rabbits repeatedly exposed to placebo control, 0.01%, 0.1% and 1.0% of Feminilove vaginal gel. Feminilove vaginal gel showed acceptable vaginal irritation (total score 1–6).
In addition, Table 3 lists the effects of Feminilove vaginal gel (0.01, 0.1, or 1.0%) on PCNA-positive cells in the vaginal epithelium and stromal cells of tissue sections from rabbits. We showed that > 24% and > 16% of epithelial cell and stromal cells, respectively, were stained for positive PCNA cells. Importantly, there was no significant difference in PCNA values between placebo control treated versus Feminilove vaginal gel treated samples.
3. Minimal systemic toxicity of Feminilove vaginal gel
We evaluated hematology parameters in rabbits treated with Feminilove vaginal gels versus placebo controls (Table 4). Importantly, hematology parameters between these 2 groups of rabbits were not different.
4. Minimal cell toxicity of Feminilove vaginal gel on reconstituted human vaginal epithelium model
In 3 models of reconstituted human vaginal cells (epithelial, cervical and endocervical epithelial cells), co-cultured with various concentration of Feminilove vaginal gel (0.01, 0.1, and 1.0%) for 24 hours did not show sign of cytotoxicity (Figure 3, left panels). Result of cell culture study is in agreement with the data when topically Feminilove vaginal gel has been applied for 10 days in female rabbits (Figure 3, right panels). Both in vitro cell culture study and in vivo rabbit study demonstrated the minimal cell toxicity of Feminilove vaginal gel.
5. Regulatory effects of Feminilove vaginal gel on the growth of uropathogenic and commensal vaginal bacteria
A significant large proportion of post-menopausal women have applied vaginal lubricating products to relieve post-menopause associated genitourinary syndrome. We compared the effects of 3 common vaginal products (Vmagic Organic Vulva Cream vaginal moisturizer, Vulvacare vaginal moisturizer & intimate skin cream, Membrasin Topical Vulua Cream for Feminine Dryness) versus Feminilove vaginal gel on growth and viability of cultured Escherichia coli and Lactobacillus crispatus. Feminilove vaginal gel significantly inhibited growth of Escherichia coli (Figure 4A). Vaginal Lactobacillus species inhibit growth of Escherichia coli. We showed that among 4 vaginal gel products, only Feminilove vaginal gel promoted the growth of Lactobacillus spp. (Figure 4B).
6. Anti-inflammatory effects of Feminilove vaginal gel in cultured human vaginal epithelial cells
Inflammation is often present in the female reproductive tract. We showed that Feminilove vaginal gel elicits an anti-inflammatory response and significantly decreased inflammatory mediators (IL-6, TNF-α and IL-1β) induced by LPS on cultured vaginal epithelial cells (Figure 5).
7. Production of surface-deposited tropoelastin and collagen in cultured vaginal smooth muscle cells
The vaginal wall and structural support of vaginal pelvis is related to content of collagen, elastin, and muscle. We showed that Feminilove vaginal gel significantly increased tropoelastin and collagen production in cultured vaginal smooth muscle cells (Figure 6).
IV. DISCUSSION
Vaginal dryness is common in women and has a significant negative impact on their sexual satisfaction and overall quality of life. Due to cultural influence, this condition is often underreported.26 In this study, we evaluated the safety and the beneficial effects of Feminilove BIO-FRESH moisturizing vaginal gel, a new type of estrogen-free vaginal gel. Our results suggest that; 1) Feminilove vaginal gel exhibits minimal cell cytotoxicity on various human vaginal cells; 2) Feminilove vaginal gel exhibits minimal side-effects on the structure of vaginal mucosa stratum of experimental animals; 3) Feminilove vaginal gel inhibits the growth of pathogenic vaginal bacteria (E. coli) while promotes the growth of beneficial vaginal bacteria (Lactobacillus spp); 4) Feminilove vaginal gel demonstrates an anti-inflammatory response on cultured vaginal epithelial cells; and 5) Feminilove vaginal gel promotes the production of tropoelastin and collagen on cultural vaginal smooth muscle and thus, may restore loose vaginal wall (i.e., tightening effects).
One of the important ingredients of Feminilove vaginal gel is aloe vera. Aloe vera is a natural product that have been frequently used in the field of cosmetology. The aloe vera plant has been used for centuries for its beneficial effects. Aloe vera contains numerous potentially active constituents such as vitamins, enzymes, mineral, sugar, lignin, saponins, salicylic acids and amino acids. The mechanism of its beneficial action includes healing properties, effects on skin rejuvenation, anti-inflammation, modulatory effects on the immune system, anti-tumor, as well as moistening and anti-aging activities.27 In addition, aloe vera exerts inhibitory action on fungi, bacteria, and viruses. Moreover, aloe vera gel possesses moisturizing and anti-aging effects. Mucopolysaccharides from aloe vera extract promotes the binding of moisture into the skin. Aloe promotes fibroblast to produce collagen and elastin and as a result, exerts its anti-aging and anti-wrinkle effects.28,29
V. CONCLUSIONS
The negative impact of vaginal dryness on quality of life is overwhelming. In our in vitro and in vivo models, we showed that Feminilove BIO-FRESH moisturizing vaginal gel is a safe and effective remedy for women with vaginal dryness and vulvovaginal atrophy.
Competing Interests
The authors declare no competing interests
Acknowledgements
Financial support for this study was provided by the Epoch NE Corporation, Seattle, WA. However, the funder has no role in the design of the study; in the collection, analyses, or interpretation of the data; in the writing of the manuscript, or in the decision to publish the results. Design of this work has followed the study guidelines from the American Gynecological & Obstetrical Society. The American Gynecological & Obstetrical Society is an organization composed of individuals attaining national prominence in scholarship in the discipline of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Women’s Health as well as to advance the health of women by providing dedicated leadership and promoting excellence in research, education and medical practice.
Footnotes
Vaginal dryness is a common symptom associated with vulvovaginal atrophy of menopause. The impact of vaginal dryness is very significant as it negatively affects quality of life, daily activities, sexual satisfaction as well as on interpersonal relationships. Symptoms of vaginal dryness is often underreported and undertreated. Recently, vaginal lubricants and moisturizers have been applied as one of the alternative and safe approaches to relieve vaginal dryness for women with mild to moderate vaginal dryness. We evaluated the safety and beneficial effects of a new type of estrogen-free vaginal gel, Feminilove BIO-FRESH moisturizing vaginal gel, using in vitro and in vivo experimental tools. Our results suggest that; 1) Feminilove vaginal gel exhibits minimal cell cytotoxicity on various human vaginal cells; 2) Feminilove vaginal gel exhibits minimal side-effects on the structure of vaginal mucosa stratum of experimental animals; 3) Feminiove vaginal gel inhibits the growth of pathogenic vaginal bacteria (E. coli) while promotes the growth of beneficial vaginal bacteria (Lactobacillus spp); 4) Feminilove vaginal gel elicits an anti-inflammatory response on vaginal epithelial cells; and 5) Feminilove vaginal gel promotes the production of tropoelastin and collagen on cultural vaginal smooth muscle and may restore loose vaginal wall (i.e., tightening effects). In summary, our results indicate that Feminilove BIO-FRESH moisturizing vaginal gel is a safe and effective remedy for vaginal dryness and vulvovaginal atrophy in women.