Short latency stretch reflexes depend on the balance of activity in agonist and antagonist muscles during ballistic elbow movements

Abstract

The spinal stretch reflex is a fundamental building block of motor function, with a sensitivity that varies continuously during movement and when changing between movement and posture. Many have investigated task-dependent reflex sensitivity, but few have provided simple, quantitative analyses of the relationship between the volitional control and stretch reflex sensitivity throughout tasks that require coordinated activity of several muscles. Here we develop such an analysis and use it to test the hypothesis that modulation of reflex sensitivity during movement can be explained by the balance of activity within agonist and antagonist muscles better than by activity only in the muscle homonymous with the reflex. Subjects completed hundreds of flexion and extension movements as small, pseudo-random perturbations of elbow angle were applied to obtain estimates of stretch reflex amplitude throughout the movement. A subset of subjects performed a postural control task at muscle activities matched to those during movement. We found that reflex modulation during movement can be described by background activity in antagonist muscles about the elbow much better than by activity only in the muscle homonymous to the reflex (p<0.001). Agonist muscle activity enhanced reflex sensitivity whereas antagonist activity suppressed it. Surprisingly, the magnitude of these effects was similar, suggesting a balance of control between agonists and antagonists very different from the dominance of sensitivity to homonymous activity during posture. This balance is due to a large decrease in sensitivity to homonymous muscle activity during movement rather than substantial changes in the influence of antagonistic muscle activity.