Super-enhancers require a combination of classical enhancers and novel facilitator elements to drive high levels of gene expression

Abstract

Super-enhancers (SEs) are a class of compound regulatory elements which control expression of key cell-identity genes. It remains unclear whether they are simply clusters of independent classical enhancer elements or whether SEs manifest emergent properties and should therefore be considered as a distinct class of element. Here, using synthetic biology and genome editing, we engineered the well characterised erythroid α-globin SE at the endogenous α-globin locus, removing all SE constituents in a mouse embryonic stem cell-line, to create a "blank canvass". This has allowed us to re-build the SE through individual and combinatorial reinsertion of its five elements (R1, R2, R3, Rm, R4), to test the importance of each constituent's sequence and position within the locus. Each re-inserted element independently creates a region of open chromatin and binds its normal repertoire of transcription factors; however, we found a high degree of functional interdependence between the five constituents. Surprisingly, the two strongest α-globin enhancers (R1 and R2) act sub-optimally both on their own and in combination, and although the other three elements (R3, Rm and R4) exhibit no discernible enhancer activity, they each exert a major positive effect in facilitating the activity of the classical enhancers (R1 and R2). This effect depends not simply on the sequence of each elements but on their positions within the cluster. We propose that these "facilitators" are a novel form of regulatory element, important for ensuring the full activity of SEs but are distinct from conventional enhancer elements.