Abstract
PARP1 is recruited and activated by DNA strand breaks, catalyzing the generation of poly-ADP-ribose (PAR) chains from NAD+. PAR relaxes chromatin and recruits other DNA repair factors, including XRCC1 and DNA Ligase 3, to maintain genomic stability. Here we show that, in contrast to the normal development of Parp1-null mice, heterozygous expression of catalytically inactive Parp1 (E988A, Parp1+/A) acts in a dominant-negative manner to disrupt murine embryogenesis. As such, all the surviving F1 Parp1+/A mice are chimeras with mixed Parp1+/AN (neoR retention) cells that act similarly to Parp1+/-. Pure F2 Parp1+/A embryos were found at Mendelian ratios at the E3.5 blastocyst stage but died before E9.5. Compared to Parp1-/- cells, genotype and expression-validated pure Parp1+/A cells retain significant ADP-ribosylation and PARylation activities but accumulate markedly higher levels of sister chromatin exchange and mitotic bridges. Despite proficiency for homologous recombination and non-homologous end-joining measured by reporter assays and supported by normal lymphocyte and germ cell development, Parp1+/A cells are hypersensitive to base damages, radiation, and Topoisomerase I and II inhibition. The sensitivity of Parp1+/A cells to base damages and Topo inhibitors in particular exceed Parp1-/- controls. The findings show that the enzymatically inactive PARP1 protein has a dominant negative role and establishes a clear physiological difference between PARP1 inactivation vs. deletion. As a result, the enzymatically inactive PARP1 has a much more deteriorating impact on normal tissues than previously estimated, providing a mechanism for the on-target side effect of PARP inhibitors used for cancer therapy.
Significance Statement PARP1 is the primary target of PARP enzymatic inhibitors. The use of PARP inhibitors for cancer therapy is based not only on the extreme sensitivity of BRCA1/2-deficient cancer cells to PARP1 inhibition but also on the nonessential role of PARP1 in normal tissues. Here we show that in contrast to the normal development of Parp1-null mice, the mouse model expressing the catalytically inactive Parp1 on only one allele (E988A, Parp1+/A) dies embryonically with high levels of genomic instability. The results reveal the severe dominant-negative impact of catalytically inactive PARP1, indicating the presence of enzymatically inactive PARP1 is much more damaging to normal tissues than previously anticipated. These findings provide a mechanism for clinical PARP inhibitors’ unexpected normal tissue toxicity.
Competing Interest Statement
The authors have declared no competing interest.
