Abstract
Mitochondrial integrity is a crucial determinant of overall cellular health. Mitochondrial dysfunction and impediments in regulating organellar homeostasis contribute majorly to the pathophysiological manifestation of several neurological disorders. Mutations in human DJ-1 (PARK7) have been implicated in the deregulation of mitochondrial homeostasis, a critical cellular etiology observed in Parkinson’s disease progression. DJ-1 is a multifunctional protein belonging to the DJ-1/ThiJ/PfpI superfamily, conserved across the phylogeny. Although the pathophysiological significance of DJ-1 has been well-established, the underlying molecular mechanism(s) by which DJ-1 paralogs modulate mitochondrial maintenance and other cellular processes remains elusive. Using Saccharomyces cerevisiae as the model organism, we unravel the intricate mechanism by which yeast DJ-1 paralogs (collectively called Hsp31 paralogs) modulate mitochondrial homeostasis. Our study establishes a genetic synthetic interaction between Ubp2, a cysteine-dependent deubiquitinase, and DJ-1 paralogs. In the absence of DJ-1 paralogs, mitochondria adapt to a highly tubular network due to enhanced expression of Fzo1. Intriguingly, the loss of Ubp2 restores the mitochondrial integrity in the DJ-1 deletion background by modulating the ubiquitination status of Fzo1. Besides, the loss of Ubp2 in the absence of DJ-1 restores mitochondrial respiration and functionality by regulating the mitophagic flux. Further, Ubp2 deletion makes cells resistant to oxidative stress without DJ-1 paralogs. For the first time, our study deciphers functional crosstalk between Ubp2 and DJ-1 in regulating mitochondrial homeostasis and cellular health.
Author Summary Mitochondria are dynamic organelles essential for generating the energy required to maintain cellular viability and drive biological processes. Mitochondrial structures undergo continuous remodeling, modulating their function in response to cellular cues. The plasticity of mitochondrial structures is due to conserved fusion-fission proteins, thus enabling cells to adapt to metabolic changes. Mutations in PARK7, encoding for DJ-1, lead to an imbalance in mitochondrial dynamics and culminate in the progression of neurodegenerative disorders such as Parkinson’s disease (PD). DJ-1 belongs to the highly conserved DJ-1/ThiJ/Pfp superfamily of multifunctional proteins. Saccharomyces cerevisiae encodes for four paralogs, which belong to the DJ-1 superfamily. Recent studies demonstrate the role of yeast DJ-1 members in regulating mitochondrial integrity and oxidative stress response. However, the mechanism(s) by which the paralogs mediate cytoprotective action remains elusive. The current study addresses the mechanistic lacuna by delineating cross-talk between Ubp2, a deubiquitinase, and redox-sensitive DJ-1 paralogs in regulating mitochondrial health. Our results suggest that elevated expression of Ubp2 in cells lacking DJ-1 paralogs promotes hyperfused mitochondrial structures. At the same time, in the absence of DJ-1 paralogs, the levels of Fzo1 expression are enhanced significantly due to its altered ubiquitination status. Intriguingly, mitochondrial dynamics and cellular health were reinstated upon deletion of Ubp2, particularly in cells with combinatorial deletion of DJ-1 paralogs in yeast. The study thus provides evidence linking the role of DJ-1 and deubiquitinase in the maintenance of mitochondrial dynamics, which can further aid in understanding the mechanism causing PD progression.
1. Introduction
The DJ-1 superfamily comprises multifunctional proteins conserved across the phylogeny [1–3]. They represent a class of proteins essential for the upkeep of cellular metabolism across various species, from prokaryotes to eukaryotes [4–10]. DJ-1 paralogs exhibit acid stress resistance in bacteria and function as glyoxalase and protease [7,11,12]. Saccharomyces cerevisiae has four paralogs, namely, Hsp31, Hsp32, Hsp33, and Hsp34, collectively called the Hsp31 paralogs, which belong to the DJ-1 superfamily. These paralogs are involved in metabolic reprogramming and cellular survival in the stationary phase [8,13]. Moreover, the Hsp31 paralogs regulate the redox status of the cells and are essential for combatting carbonyl and concomitant oxidative stress [14–16]. Under oxidative stress conditions, the Hsp31 paralogs redistribute to mitochondria and provide cytoprotection by their deglycase, glyoxalase, and chaperoning activities [5,14,16]. Additionally, reports suggest that Hsp31 paralogs remodel the mitochondrial pool and modulate the etiology of protein aggregation in models of neurodegenerative disorders such as Parkinson’s disease (PD), Alzheimer’s disease (AD), and Huntington’s disease [5,13,15]
In humans, mutations in PARK7 (encodes human DJ-1) are responsible for the progression of familial forms of PD [17–20]. Comparable to its orthologs from other genera, human DJ-1 is a multifunctional protein that controls transcription and redox status and preserves mitochondrial health [21–24]. Several biochemical studies also demonstrate the neuroprotective functions of human DJ-1 due to its functions as glyoxalase, protease, and a chaperone [10,25–27]. These proteins also control cell survival and perform cytoprotective actions through their significant involvement in signaling pathways [28–30]. Moreover, the knockdown of DJ-1 in human cell lines leads to mitochondrial structure and function disruption, ultimately leading to oxidative stress [31,32]. Overexpression of the pathogenic mutants of DJ-1 leads to mitochondrial fragmentation and dysfunction and enhanced sensitivity to oxidative stressors [33]. Notably, it is known that DJ-1 homologs in yeast, humans, and plants redistribute to mitochondria in response to oxidative stress to safeguard organellar function [9,14,16]. Furthermore, overexpressing human DJ-1 in yeast reduced mitochondrial superoxide levels and functionally supplemented Hsp31, demonstrating the functional conservation between species [1,14]. However, even though DJ-1 has been identified as a crucial modulator of mitochondrial integrity across the genera, its mechanism of regulating organellar health remains elusive.
Mitochondria are dynamic organelles that undergo cycles of fusion and fission in response to various metabolic cues in the cell. The PD-associated DJ-1 mutants cause an imbalance in mitochondrial dynamics by affecting the expression of Drp1, a conserved GTPase required for mitochondrial fission [31]. Similarly, in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, cells lacking Hsp31 paralogs cause perturbed mitochondrial dynamics due to altered expression of Fzo1 [15]. Fzo1 is the critical mediator of mitochondrial fusion and is well-established among the dynamin family proteins [34]. An orchestrated action of inner (Mgm1) and outer membrane proteins (Fzo1, Ugo1) regulates fusion in yeast [35]. These evolutionarily conserved GTPase activities are regulated by several post-translational modifications, including proteolytic processing, ubiquitylation, sumoylation, phosphorylation, and dephosphorylation [36]. Tethering of neighboring mitochondrial membranes is initiated by the oligomerization of Fzo1, eventually leading to the fusion of the outer membrane [37]. Ubiquitination is one of the critical processes that regulate the fusogenic activity of Fzo1 on the mitochondrial outer membrane [38].Their ubiquitination status dictates the fate of mitochondrial fusion proteins in the outer membrane. The ubiquitination-deubiquitination pathway determines the homeostatic balance of fusion and fission [39]. It is well-known that ubiquitination directs proteins to proteasomal complex for degradation, and recent studies indicate that there can be many other biological outcomes owing to the diversity of ubiquitin chain linkages [40,41]. Deubiquitinases (DUBs) constitute a class of enzymes that catalyze the process of removing ubiquitin from ubiquitinated proteins, thus rescinding the ubiquitination process [42]. The contrasting action of deubiquitinases is a crucial regulatory step in this complex process [39]. Fzo1 turnover is regulated by a class of cysteine-dependent proteases with opposing actions. Ubp2 and Ubp12 are the thiol-dependent, ubiquitin-specific proteases with antagonistic functions in stabilizing Fzo1 [39]. Notably, the ubiquitination status of mitofusins is a significant determinant of mitochondrial dynamics, which in turn helps cells adapt to a variety of conditions [43,44]. Ubiquitin chain editing by the deubiquitinases adds another level of regulation that dictates the status of mitofusins. The action of Ubp2 is essential for stabilizing the ‘pro-fusion’ ubiquitin chain on Fzo1. Thus, cells lacking Ubp2 display fragmented mitochondrial morphology. However, another thiol-dependent deubiquitinase, called Ubp12, removes the ‘pro-fusion’ ubiquitin tags from Fzo1 and directs it to proteasomal degradation [45]. The balance of these antagonistic DUBs is maintained by a cell division cycle protein, Cdc48 [39]. This mounting evidence thus suggests a plausible cross-talk between Hsp31 paralogs and the deubiquitinase cascade by which mitochondrial dynamics are regulated.
By utilizing Saccharomyces cerevisiae as the model system, the current study outlines the mechanism by which Ubp2 and the redox-sensitive DJ-1 paralogs functionally cooperate to maintain mitochondrial health and integrity. Ubp2, a deubiquitinase required for retaining the fusogenic population of Fzo1, was identified to interact genetically with yeast DJ-1 members, particularly Hsp31 and Hsp34. The mitochondrial structure and function were restored upon deletion of Ubp2 in the combinatorial absence of Hsp31 and Hsp34. Moreover, the deletion of Hsp31 paralogs sensitizes the cells to oxidative stress. However, the oxidative stress sensitivity was partially alleviated in cells lacking Ubp2 in conjunction with Hsp31 paralogs. Taken together, our findings provide evidence for delineating a functional cross-talk between Hsp31 paralogs and Ubp2 by altering the ubiquitination status of Fzo1, which regulates mitochondrial dynamics.
2. Results
2.1 Deletion of Ubp2 restores respiratory growth defects in the absence of Hsp31 paralogs
Mitochondrial structure and function are essential indices of cellular health and have been studied extensively owing to the dynamicity of the organelle. The Hsp31 paralogs in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which belong to the DJ-1 superfamily, have been identified as crucial modulators of mitochondrial health [14,15]. It has been reported that a combinatorial deletion of Hsp31 and Hsp34 results in a growth defect in glycerol at non-permissive temperatures, suggesting the role of Hsp31 paralogs in maintaining mitochondrial integrity [15]. Alteration in the expression of Fzo1 due to the absence of Hsp31 paralogs manifests as an increase in hyperfused mitochondrial structures. However, the mechanism by which these paralogs perturb the mitochondrial dynamics remains elusive.
The process of fusion is a finely orchestrated mechanism mediated by the action of a conserved class of cysteine-dependent deubiquitinases. Recent evidence suggests that Ubp2 is a crucial modulator of mitochondrial dynamics and essential for maintaining the fusogenic status of Fzo1 [46]. Since Hsp31 paralogs regulate Fzo1 expression and mitochondrial dynamics, we investigated a possible functional cross-talk between Ubp2 and Hsp31 paralogs. Using yeast genetic manipulation, we created an Δubp2 in the W303 strain background. The deletion of Ubp2 (Δubp2) leads to an impairment in the growth in both complete (S.C. Dextrose) and non-fermentable media (S.C. Glycerol) at non-permissive temperatures of 24 °C and 37 °C (Fig. 1A). At the same time, among the four Hsp31 paralogs, only the cells lacking Hsp31(Δ31) exhibit a compromised phenotype in glycerol at a non-permissive temperature of 37 °C (Fig. 1A) [15]. The cells lacking Hsp34 (Δ34) have growth comparable to WT cells. However, together deletion with Hsp31 (Δ31Δ34) leads to severely compromised growth in glycerol in conditions of heat stress at 37 °C (Fig. 1A). To test a genetic interaction between Hsp31 paralogs (Hsp31 and Hsp34) and Ubp2, we constructed combination of deletion strains lacking Ubp2 in the background of Δ31(Δ31Δubp2), Δ34(Δ34Δubp2) and Δ31Δ34 (Δ31Δ34Δubp2). Interestingly, the strains Δ31Δubp2 and Δ34Δubp2 alone had a more compromised growth phenotype in glycerol at 37 °C, comparable to Δubp2 (Fig. S1). Intriguingly, on the other hand, the deletion of Ubp2 in the absence of 31 paralogs (Δ31Δ34Δubp2)showed rescue in the growth phenotype comparable to WT in a non-fermentable carbon source and non-permissive temperature of 37 °C (Fig. 1A).
To determine whether the growth rescue by the Ubp2 in the absence of Hsp31 paralogs is due to the consequence of its regulated expression, we analyzed first the levels of Ubp2 in WT and Δ31Δ34 strains. To test this, Ubp2 was genomically tagged with hemagglutinin (HA) at the C-terminus and expressed in WT and Δ31Δ34. The whole cell lysates were subjected to immunoblotting and probed for the Ubp2 levels. The immunoblot analysis revealed that Δ31Δ34 strains showed up to a 2.5-fold increment in the expression of Ubp2 levels (Fig. 1B, C). At the same time, WT cells exhibit a significant reduction in Ubp2 expression in the late log phase compared to the cells collected from the mid-log phase (Fig. S2, compare lanes 1 and 3). However, Ubp2 expression remained unaltered in Δ31Δ34 across mid-log (6h) and late-log (12h) phases (Fig. S2, compare lanes 2 and 4), suggesting Hsp31-dependent regulated expression of Ubp2 as a function of the growth phase. To further ascertain this observation, the Ubp2 as the molecular player in regulating the growth defect in Δ31Δ34, we overexpressed Ubp2 (under TEF promoter) in the background of Δubp2, Δ31Δ34Δubp2, and subjected the strains to growth analysis. The phenotypic assessment in glycerol indicated that Ubp2 overexpression in Δubp2 shows a phenotype comparable to WT. In contrast, Ubp2 overexpression in Δ31Δ34Δleads to growth sensitivity in glycerol at 37 °C, equivalent to Δ31Δ34 alone (Fig. 1D). These experimental evidence suggest a strong functional cross-talk between Hsp31 paralogs and Ubp2 in terms of regulating respiratory growth in conditions of heat stress.
2.2 Ubp2 regulates mitochondrial integrity and turnover in cells lacking Hsp31 paralogs
The phenotypic growth defects in respiratory deficient conditions are closely correlated to perturbance of mitochondrial health. Therefore, we assessed mitochondrial-specific functional parameters across all the strains. In particular, the changes in the mitochondrial morphology are assessed to ascertain the overall cellular health. To microscopically visualize mitochondrial structures, the cells were transformed with MTS-mCherry constructs that specifically translocate to the organelle due to targeting sequence and decorate the mitochondria [14]. In agreement with the previous findings, the Δubp2 strain exhibited fragmented mitochondria [46] (Fig. 2A, compare panels 2 with panel 1). In contrast, the Δ31Δ34 strain showed hyperfused mitochondrial morphology [15] (Fig. 2A, compare panels 3 with 1). Most interestingly, upon deletion of Ubp2 in Δ31Δ34 background, mitochondrial morphology was reversed, which now closely resembles the WT cells (Fig. 2A, compare panels 4 with panel 1). The fragmented, intermediate, and tubular states of the mitochondria were subjected to quantification for each respective strain. The results highlight that the cells exhibiting intermediate mitochondrial morphology in Δ31Δ34Δubp2 are comparable to that of the WT in correlation with the reversal of growth phenotype (Fig. 2B) compared to the extensive tubular network observed in Δ31Δ34 strain. On the other hand, Ubp2 deletion in the background of single deletion strains of Hsp31 paralogs (Δ31Δubp2, Δ34Δubp2) exhibited fragmented mitochondria, comparable to the Δubp2 strain (Fig. S3).
As we observed varied mitochondrial structures across the different strains, we probed for the total and functional mitochondrial mass change using flow cytometric analysis. NAO is used specifically for staining cardiolipin, an indicator of the total mitochondrial mass in cells. Upon flow cytometry, deletion of Ubp2 did not show a significant difference in the total mitochondrial mass compared to WT (Fig. 2B). However, the Δ31Δ34 strain exhibited a substantial increase in the total mitochondrial mass, as reported previously [15]. Interestingly, there was no difference in the total mitochondrial mass in Δ31Δ34Δubp2, and it was comparable to Δ31Δ34 (Fig. 2B). This indicates that deletion of Ubp2 in the background of WT and Δ31Δ34 does not alter the total mitochondrial mass. The functionality of mitochondria was assessed by staining the cells with a potentiometric dye, JC-1, and subjecting them to flow cytometric analysis. A significant decrease in the functional mitochondrial content in Δubp2 was observed compared to WT (Fig. 2C). Contrastingly, the Δ31Δ34 strain exhibited a significant increase in the functional mitochondrial mass, as reported previously. Strikingly, the deletion of Ubp2 in the background of Δ31Δ34 restored the functional mitochondrial mass comparable to WT (Fig. 2C). Furthermore, as mitochondrial function is closely associated with respiration status leading to ATP generation, we measured the mitochondrial ATP levels across all the strains. Corroborating the previous data, we found a significant decrease in ATP levels in cells lacking Ubp2, while Δ31Δ34 exhibit higher ATP levels. At the same time, the ATP levels in Δ31Δ34Δubp2 have restored to WT, consistent with the reversal of mitochondrial-specific phenotypes correlating to the suppression of growth defects(Fig. 2E). These results suggest that Ubp2 plays a crucial role in maintaining functional mitochondrial mass in conjunction with Hsp31 paralogs.
Mitochondrial homeostasis is regulated by mitophagy, which clears the damaged and aged mitochondria [47]. We observed that loss of Ubp2 does not affect the total mitochondrial mass, albeit involving the functional mitochondrial pool. We assayed the strains for organellar turnover to investigate whether Ubp2 has a role in modulating mitophagy. Mitophagy is monitored by tagging the outer mitochondrial membrane protein (OM45) with GFP at the C-terminus and subjecting the strains to microscopic and immunoblotting analysis [48]. The cells were grown in dextrose until the mid-log phase and then in glycerol for the subsequent time points as indicated. Samples were collected, and cells were lysed for analysis using immunoblotting. The results suggest that the process of mitophagy is initiated in the WT strain after 36 h of mitophagy induction (Fig. 3A). On the other hand, the Δubp2 exhibits mitophagy initiation at 24 h of induction, probably due to the presence of fragmented smaller mitochondrial structures. However, the intensity of the processed GFP in Δubp2 is less than the WT at the same time points. This indicates that even though mitophagy is initiated at an earlier time in Δubp2, clearance of damaged mitochondria is slower than the WT, accumulating fragmented and nonfunctional mitochondrial mass. Opposingly, Δ31Δ34 showed slower mitophagy induction after 54 h of growth in glycerol due to the presence of hyperfused mitochondrial structures (Fig. 3A). Interestingly, Δ31Δ34Δubp2, which has restored mitochondrial integrity exhibits kinetically faster mitochondrial clearance by induction observed at 36h as compared to Δ31Δ34 alone. However, the intensity of processed GFP is less than Δ31Δ34 and not comparable to WT, suggesting that Ubp2 deletion partially suppresses the process of mitophagic flux. The mitophagy deficient Δatg32 strain served as a negative control for GFP processing (Fig. 3A, last panels).
To validate the results further, we also subjected the strains to microscopy to observe the vacuolar internalization of processed GFP. In correlation with the immunoblotting results, Δubp2 exhibits processed GFP comparable to WT. Still, the fluorescence intensity was higher than WT after 48 h of mitophagy induction indicating fater turnover (Fig. 3B, compare panels 1 and 2). Similarly, OM45-GFP is internalized to a lesser extent in Δ31Δ34 compared to Δ31Δ34Δubp2 (Fig. 3B, compare panels 3 and 4). However, the level of processed OM-45 GFP fluorescence intensity in Δ31Δ34Δubp2 is lesser than WT, indicating that Ubp2 partially restores the mitophagic turnover. The cells are deficient in mitophagy (Δatg32), did not show any processed OM-45 GFP fluorescence in the vacuole, and were used as a negative control (Fig. 3B, compare panels 1-4 with 5).
2.3 Fzo1 levels and turnover are restored upon deletion of Ubp2 in the absence of Hsp31 paralogs
The expression and stability of proteins like Fzo1 and Dnm1 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae determine the dynamicity of the mitochondria [49]. Our results exclusively highlight variations in mitochondrial health, and we analyzed for changes in the expression of mitochondrial dynamic proteins. In agreement with previous findings, we observed a significant decrease in Fzo1 levels in Δubp2 compared to WT (Fig. 4A & B). In contrast, a substantial increment in the expression of Fzo1 was observed in Δ31Δ34 strains [15] (Fig. 4A & B). Interestingly, Δ31Δ34Δubp2 exhibited a restoration in levels of Fzo1, comparable to WT (Fig. 4A & B). Furthermore, there were no significant differences in the expression of fission protein Dnm1 across the strains (Fig. S4). The results further suggest that the absence of both Hsp31 paralogs and Ubp2 keeps the levels of Dnm1 unaltered in the cells, which is in agreement with the previous findings [15, 46].
As there was a restoration of Fzo1 steady-state levels in Δ31Δ34Δubp2, we tested for the turnover rate of Fzo1 across the four strains by utilizing the cycloheximide chase assay (CHX). The turnover kinetics revealed that Fzo1 has a shorter half-life in Δubp2 compared to WT (Fig. 4C & D). As opposed to Δubp2, the Δ31Δ34 strain exhibited stable expression of Fzo1, correlating with the increased steady-state expression (Fig. 4C & D). However, Δ31Δ34Δubp2 exhibits restoration of Fzo1 dynamics, comparable to WT (Fig. 4C & D).
Next, we determined if the altered Fzo1 levels are ubiquitinated as ubiquitin conjugation on Fzo1 can contribute to fusion or direct it towards proteolysis. The fusogenic ability depends on the ubiquitination status of the Fzo1 protein, dictated by the activity of Ubp2 [39]. To further investigate the ubiquitination status of the strains, we tagged Fzo1 C-terminally using hemagglutinin (HA) tag. The strains were then subjected to immunoprecipitation and pulled down using HA-specific antibodies. The pull-down fraction was subjected to immunoblotting and probed with an anti-ubiquitin antibody. We observed that the absence of Ubp2 leads to increased ubiquitination of Fzo1 as compared to WT (Fig. 4E). However, Δ31Δ34 exhibits a marked decrease in the ubiquitination status of Fzo1, corroborating with its increased stability in the absence of Hsp31 paralogs. Interestingly, there was a significant restoration in the levels of ubiquitinated Fzo1 in Δ31Δ34Δubp2 as it is comparable to WT (Fig. 4E and F). These findings highlight that the ubiquitination status of Fzo1 dictates its stability and turnover kinetics across the strains.
2.4 Ubp2 deletion restores cell cycle progression in cells lacking Hsp31 paralogs
Mitochondrial structure transition is integral for the cells to advance into subsequent cell cycle phases [50]. Previous studies indicate that cells lacking Hsp31 paralogs switch to hyperfused mitochondrial structures as an adaptive strategy to ameliorate the increased ROS levels. At the same time, this adaptive strategy is detrimental to cell cycle progression, as observed in the Δ31Δ34 strain [15]. Therefore, we hypothesized that remission of hyperfused mitochondrial structures in Δ31Δ34Δubp2 would restore the cell cycle progression.
To test this hypothesis, the strains were arrested at the G1 phase using alpha factor and synchronously released in dextrose media. Subsequently, the cells were fixed and subjected to flow cytometric analysis. Upon deletion of Ubp2, the cells exhibited no delay in cell cycle progression and resembled WT. The loss of Ubp2 does not cause perturbation in a cell cycle, as the mitochondrial distribution remains unaffected. However, the Δ31Δ34 strain exhibited cell cycle arrest at the G2/M phase (from t=60 min to t=80 min), per the presence of hyperfused mitochondrial structures [15]. (Fig. 5A). Interestingly, restoration of mitochondrial integrity in Δ31Δ34Δubp2 led to the usual progression in cell cycle and is comparable to the WT. Taken together, the results indicate that remission of mitochondrial structures upon deletion of Ubp2 in the absence of Hsp31 paralogs enables the cells to undergo unimpeded progression through the cell cycle.
The progression of the normal cell cycle is well correlated with cell size and growth. Hence, we determined the change in cell size. Microscopic analysis revealed that Δ31Δ34 has 30% of the cells exhibiting increased cell size than WT (more than 5-6 µm) and, in the stationary phase, exhibit pseudohyphal characteristics (Fig. 5B and Fig. 5C) [15]. On the other hand, Δubp2 cells exhibits normal cell size compared to WT. Interestingly, Δ31Δ34Δubp2 has reversed the cell population with a size similar to the WT (Fig. 5B and Fig. 5C). Thus, balanced mitochondrial dynamics are integral in maintaining cell cycle and cell size.
2.5 Ubp2 regulates basal ROS lelevls in the absence of Hsp31 paralogs
Active mitochondrial respiration contributes significantly to the pool of cellular basal ROS levels. Hence, we probed for the basal levels of ROS across the strains. The yeast cells grown in dextrose-containing media were treated with ROS sensing dye, H2DCFDA, and subjected to flow cytometric and microscopic analysis to measure the total cellular ROS levels. The flow cytometry data reveals that Δubp2 has basal ROS levels comparable to WT. A significant increase in the basal ROS levels was observed in Δ31Δ34, consistent with the previous findings (Fig. 6A) [15]. Interestingly, the basal ROS levels were significantly restored in Δ31Δ34Δubp2 and the levels comparable to WT (Fig. 6A). These findings further confirmed by microscopic analysis with H2DCFDA dye staining. Like flow cytometric data, a significant increment in green fluorescence intensity was observed for Δ31Δ34 strains. On the other hand, the green fluorescence was significantly restored in Δ31Δ34Δubp2 strains, similar to WT and Δubp2 strains (Fig. 6B).
The basal mitochondrial specific ROS was probed using mitochondrial specific dye, MitoSOX. The cells grown in dextrose-containing media were subjected to flow cytometry and microscopic analysis. The flow cytometric data revealed a non-significant difference in basal mitochondrial ROS in Δubp2 strain, which is comparable to WT. However, a two-fold increment in mitochondrial ROS was observed in Δ31Δ34 (Fig. 6C). Interestingly, the mitochondrial ROS levels of Δ31Δ34Δubp2 were restored to WT (Fig. 6C). To substantiate the flow cytometry results, the microscopic analysis performed using MitoSOX dye. The total mitochondrial ROS levels in WT and Δubp2 were comparable (Fig. 6D, compare panels 1 and 2). A significant increment in basal mitochondrial ROS in Δ31Δ34 was evident upon the microscopic analysis (Fig. 6D, compare panels 1 and 3). Consistent with the above findings, Δ31Δ34Δubp2 exhibits a significant restoration of mitochondrial ROS distribution in comparison to WT (Fig. 6D, compare panels 1 and 4), which is well correlated with the reversal of mitochondrial integrity and functions
2.6 Ubp2 modulates oxidative stress sensitivity in GSH dependent manner
Our experiments provide compelling evidence highlighting the significance of balanced mitochondrial dynamics in maintaining normal cellular growth. The findings also suggest that the mitochondrial integrity is restored in Δ31Δ34Δubp2 strain due to the suppression of basal ROS levels. As mitochondrial health is directly correlated to restoration in the basal and mitochondrial ROS, we further probed for the response of the strains in the presence of extraneous oxidative stress. To test, the yeast cells from the mid-log phase were subjected to 1 mM H2O2 treatment, followed by growth analysis by spot test. The results reveal that Δubp2 is not sensitive to extraneous oxidative stress as the growth is comparable to WT. On the other hand, Δ31Δ34 showed maximum sensitivity to oxidative stress, consistent with previous findings [15]. Strikingly, the Δ31Δ34Δubp2 strain showed partial restoration of sensitivity to extraneous stress (Fig. 7A). The growth phenotype is more sensitive than the WT but significantly less sensitive than Δ31Δ34 alone (Fig. 7A).
Our results indicate that cross-talk between Ubp2 and Hsp31 paralogs regulates mitochondrial dynamics via Fzo1 and contributes to oxidative stress response. The glutathione pool is a crucial indicator of oxidative stress, wherein the reduced form of glutathione (GSH) acts as a ROS scavenger and mitigates oxidative stress. GSSG is the oxidized form of glutathione, which increases significantly in conditions of oxidative stress to cells. Interestingly, the GSH and GSSG ratio is also a crucial indicator of mitochondrial fusion, whereby GSSG mediates the stability of mitofusins and promotes mitochondrial fusion in conditions of oxidative stress [51]. As our results indicate that mitochondrial remodeling via Fzo1 is a consequence of oxidative stress response, we further probed for the GSH levels using monochlorobimaine (MCB). Monochlorobimine is a cell-permeable nonfluorescent probe that shows fluorescence only when it reacts with the reduced glutathione pool in cells. Cells in the mid-log phase were treated with MCB and subjected to microscopy and flow cytometric analysis. It is evident from microscopic analysis that Δubp2 does not show any difference in MCB staining as the fluoresces intensity is comparable to WT (Fig. 7B). This corroborates well with the fact that Fzo1 stability is altered without affecting the redox parameters in the absence of Ubp2. Interestingly, Δ31Δ34 exhibits a significant decrease in GSH levels, as indicated by the minimal MCB fluorescence in cells lacking Hsp31 paralogs (Fig. 7B). As mitochondrial parameters of Δ31Δ34 are altered in a redox-dependent manner by perturbation of the fusion protein, the GSH pool is also altered significantly. Most interestingly, Δ31Δ34Δubp2 exhibit restored levels of GSH, correlating with the restoration of mitochondrial health and redox parameters (Fig. 7B).
Furthermore, the flow cytometric analysis indicated a similar pattern of MCB uptake across the indicated strains. GSH levels remain unaltered in Δubp2 and are comparable to WT (Fig. 7C). In line with the microscopic results, flow cytometric analysis showed a significant decrement in GSH levels in Δ31Δ34 strain. At the same time, Δ31Δ34Δubp2 exhibits restored GSH levels comparable to WT (Fig. 7B). In summary, our observations firmly establish a cross-talk between Ubp2 and Hsp31 paralogs in maintaining mitochondrial health in normal physiological conditions and under oxidative stress.
3. Discussion
Balanced mitochondrial dynamics is one of the critical aspects that assist cells in maintaining a healthy mitochondrial pool. An imbalance in mitochondrial dynamics is one of the common denominators in the progression of several pathological disorders, such as cancers and neurodegenerative disorders [52,53]. One of the well-studied neurodegenerative diseases, such as Parkinson’s disorder (PD), is caused by genetic mutations in the PARK7 gene, which encodes for DJ-1 [17,20,58]. Early evidence suggests that the DJ-1 maintains mitochondrial homeostasis by modulating the conserved mitochondrial dynamic proteins[15,23,24,31-33].As the members of the DJ-1 family are ubiquitous, they perform many similar functions throughout the phylogeny. S. cerevisiae consists of four paralogs belonging to the DJ-1 family, which modulate mitochondrial integrity and oxidative stress response [14,15] Previous findings also highlight that Hsp34 paralog sensitizes the function of Hsp31, whereby the cells lacking both Hsp31 & 34 have a perturbation in mitochondrial dynamics (Fig. 8) [15]. The perturbed mitochondrial dynamics in the absence of Hsp31 paralogs is due to altered expression of mitochondrial fusion protein, particularly Fzo1 (Fig. 8). However, the molecular mechanism of how DJ-1 paralogs modulate mitochondrial dynamics through fusion protein is still elusive across phylogeny.
Yeast Fzo1 belongs to a conserved class of mitofusins essential for the fusion of the outer mitochondrial membrane. Several studies indicate that the ubiquitination of mitofusin is altered in response to stress and is critical for regulating mitophagy, apoptosis, and maintenance of ER-mitochondrial contacts [54,55]. Taken together, the ubiquitination of mitofusins is pivotal in regulating mitochondrial dynamics and cellular adaptability to metabolic cues [45,56]. In S. cerevisiae, the fusogenic activity of Fzo1 is finely regulated by conserved Ubp2, which stabilizes the ‘pro-fusion’ ubiquitin chain on Fzo1 and prevents its degradation (Fig. 8) [39,46]. Therefore, yeast cells lacking Ubp2 exhibit growth sensitivity on a non-fermentable carbon source at 37°C due to the accumulation of fragmented, non-functional mitochondria, thus highlighting its role in regulating mitochondrial health in response to heat stress.
In line with this evidence, the present study establishes first-time a genetic cross-talk between Ubp2, a key mediator in modulating DJ-1-dependent mitochondrial dynamics in eucaryotes. The cells lacking Ubp2 in the absence of both Hsp31 & 34 paralogs fully restore the healthy pool of mitochondria, further substantiating a functional dependency between DJ-paralogs and Ubp2 in maintaining mitochondrial health. The expression of Ubp2 is variable in different phases of cellular growth. On the contrary, Ubp2 levels elevated but remained unaltered in cells lacking Hsp31 paralogs in various growth phases, suggesting that DJ-1 paralogs regulate the growth phase-dependent expression of Ubp2. Moreover, the increased expression of Ubp2 contributes to the increased stability of Fzo1 in Δ31Δ34 cells, thus mediating elevated events of mitochondrial fusion (Fig. 8). Recent studies elicit the role of Ubp2 in protecting Fzo1 from proteasomal degradation by cleaving the ubiquitylated forms of Fzo1, which repress mitochondrial fusion (Fig. 8) [39,45]. Nevertheless, the increased stability of Fzo1 in the absence of Hsp31 paralogs is due to reduced ubiquitination of the Fzo1. On the contrary, cells lacking Ubp2 exhibit reduced stability of Fzo1 due to the elevated levels of ubiquitinated moieties (Fig. 8). At the same time, the stability and ubiquitination status of Fzo1 in Δ31Δ34Δubp2 cells is reinstated to the WT level, thus validating that Ubp2 functions in conjunction with Hsp31 paralogs and affects the mitochondrial dynamics exclusively via Fzo1 (Fig. 8).
Mitochondrial structures, plasticity, and transport are crucial determinants of cell cycle progression [57]. The cells lacking both Hsp31 & 34, which exhibit hyperfused mitochondrial structures, cause a delay in the G2/M phase of the cell cycle. However, restoring mitochondrial dynamicity in the absence of Ubp2 in cells lacking DJ-1 paralogs reverses the delay in G2/M progression and resumes normal cell cycle progression. This further underscores the importance of functional interaction between Hsp31 paralogs and Ubp2 in maintaining the cell cycle by regulating mitochondrial integrity.
Mitochondrial structure and function are closely intertwined and critical for regulating redox homeostasis. Hsp31 paralogs are known to protect cells from carbonyl stress, thereby alleviating the concomitant formation of ROS species. Hence, cells lacking Hsp31 paralogs exhibit elevated levels of basal ROS [16]. This is mainly due to cells lacking Hsp31 paralogs exhibiting enhanced functional networked mitochondrial structures as an adaptive strategy, thereby increasing basal ROS levels [15]. However, this adaptive strategy is detrimental to the cells due to their susceptibility to oxidative stress. Upon deletion of Ubp2 together with the Hsp31 paralogs suppresses the mitochondrial hyperfusion, thereby restoring the basal redox homeostasis (Fig. 8). Further, Ubp2 is involved in oxidative stress response whereby Ubp2 is inactivated under H2O2 stress [40]. Moreover, the cells lacking Ubp2 and Hsp31 paralogs are more resistant to extraneous oxidative stress. This further underlines the crucial role of Ubp2 in regulating stress response and bolsters the link between Ubp2 and redox-sensitive Hsp31 paralogs.
Our study provides crucial findings that elucidate the cross-talk between Ubp2 and DJ-1 paralogs for the first time in regulating mitochondrial health. In humans, DJ-1 is a neuroprotective protein orthologous to yeast Hsp31 paralogs and is crucial for maintaining a healthy cellular environment. The familial mutations in the human DJ-1 (PARK7) protein cause severe pathophysiological manifestations leading to neurodegeneration in PD. Notably, the mutations disrupt mitochondrial structure and function, eventually affecting the oxidative stress sensitivity of the cells. Owing to the significance of DJ-1 in maintaining mitochondrial health, our study unravels the mechanism by which DJ-1 paralogs regulate mitochondrial dynamics in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The knowledge of molecular intricacies that integrate functions of deubiquitinase and DJ-1 via mitochondrial regulation can provide better insights into mechanistic understanding of Parkinson’s disease progression.
4. Materials and methods
4.1 Generation of yeast strains and plasmid construction
The yeast strains utilized in this study are mentioned in supplementary file 1. Deletions were done using homologous recombination in the background of BY4741 (MATα his3Δ1 leu2Δ0 met15Δ0 ura3Δ0). Strains with deletions of Hsp31 paralogs (Δ31, Δ34, and Δ31Δ34) were generated previously in the lab [14]. Ubp2 was knocked out by generating an appropriate DNA cassette comprising regions homologous to 5’ and 3’ UTR of the gene UBP2 using primer sets P5/P6, with nat1 as the selection marker. The cassette was transformed in WT, Δ31, Δ34, and Δ31Δ34 and consequently, Δubp2, Δ31Δubp2, Δ34Δubp2, Δ31Δ34Δubp2 strains were generated. Subsequently, the deletion strains were confirmed using primers P7 and P8.
For cell cycle analysis, Δbar1 and Δ31Δ34Δbar1 were generated previously in the lab [15], and Δ31Δ34Δubp2Δbar1 was generated using primers P5 and P6. All the deletions were confirmed using the primers P7/P8. Ubp2, Fzo1, and Dnm1 were HA-tagged genomically at the C-terminus by transforming the indicated strains with DNA cassettes encoding for hphNT1resistance gene with P9/P10, P1/P2, and P12/P13, respectively. UBP2 with HA tag at C-terminus was cloned into pRS415 plasmid with TEF promoter for complementation studies. The constructed plasmid was transformed into Δubp2 and Δ31Δ34Δubp2. For mitochondria visualization with a microscope, the strains were transformed with a previously constructed plasmid expressing MTS-mCherry under the influence of TEF promoter [14].
4.2 Western blot analysis
The indicated strains were subjected to growth until the log phase (A600 = 0.6-0.8 OD) or until the stationary phase (A600 = 1-2 O.D.) in necessary experiments. An equal O.D. (A600 = 2.5 OD) was pelleted for the indicated strains and subjected to incubation with 10% TCA (trichloroacetic acid) at 4 °C. It was followed by acetone washes and subjected to lysis by bead beating method. Acid-washed glass beads were added to the dried pellets along with 1X SDS dye (50 mM Tris-HCl, pH 6.8, 2% SDS, 0.1% bromophenol blue, 10% glycerol, and 100 mM β-mercaptoethanol). Consequently, the samples were heated at 92 °C for 15 min, followed by a spin at 14,000 rpm at room temperature (23-25 °C). The supernatant was loaded onto different percentages of SDS-polyacrylamide gels depending on the molecular weights of the protein to be separated and probed. The total protein content in each strain was quantified by staining the polyacrylamide gel and normalized for equal loading. The samples were transferred to an activated PVDF membrane for immunoblotting analysis. The blots were first blocked in 0.1% TBST skim milk, followed by multiple washes with 0.1% TBST. The blots incubated with the respective primary and secondary antibodies followed by probing with luminol solution (BioRad).
4.3 Microscopic analysis
The mitochondrial morphology was analyzed for indicated strains by transforming the mTS-mCherry construct. Due to the mitochondrial targeting signal sequence, the mitochondria were decorated explicitly with mCherry and visualized using a Delta Vision Elite microscope at 100X magnification. The transformed cells were collected from the mid-log phase and spread on agar padding. These non-fixed cells were subjected to microscopic analysis.
To measure the ROS with specific-dyes (H2DCFDA and MitoSox), cells from the mid-log phase were subjected to staining with the respective dyes in the dark. After incubation of the cells with dye for 30 min, the cells were washed with sterile PBS. The dye-treated cells were spread on agarose padding and subjected to microscopy analysis at 100x magnification.
4.4 Measurement of total and functional mitochondrial mass
Total mitochondrial mass was measured by staining the cells with cardiolipin-specific dye called nonyl acridine orange (NAO). Cells from the mid-log phase (A600 = 0.6 OD) were treated with NAO for 30 min (in the dark) at 30 °C at 900 rpm. Similarly, cells from the mid-log phase were treated with a potentiometric sensitive dye called JC-1 to measure the functional mitochondrial mass. Subsequently, the cells were washed in sterile PBS and subjected to flow cytometric analysis (BD FACS verse).
4.5 Pull down analysis
The ubiquitination status of Fzo1 was determined by the pull-down assay performed according to a previously established protocol [59]. Briefly, 200 mL of culture from the mid log phase (A600 = 0.6 OD) was pelleted down and suspended in ice-cold immunoprecipitation (IP) buffer (1 M Tris pH= 7.5, 5 M NaCl, 0.5 M EDTA). The slurry was subjected to bead beating (1 min, four cycles) with intermittent incubation on ice. The lysed cells were centrifuged at 16000 rpm for 5 min at 4 °C. The supernatant (containing the cytosolic fraction) was discarded, and the pellet (containing all the membrane fractions) was subjected to solubilization using IP buffer containing 0.5% Nonidet P-40 (NP-40). The membrane fraction was solubilized using a nutator at 4 °C for 2 h. Meanwhile, Protein G beads were equilibrated with IP buffer and were incubated with HA-specific antibody (10 rpm, 4 °C, 2 h). Consequently, the antibody equilibrated agarose beads were incubated with the solubilized membrane fraction for binding (10 rpm, 4 °C, 12 h). The protein bound beads was eluted with loading dye and separated on 8% SDS-PAGE gel and subjected to blotting on PVDF-memebrane (37.5:1 ratio of acrylamide: polyacrylamide) [60]. The blots were incubated with either with anti-HA or anti-ubiquitin antibodies followed by probing with luminol solution (BioRad)
4.6 Estimation of ROS levels
To probe for the basal cellular and mitochondria specific ROS, cells from mid-log phase were treated with H2DCFDA and MitoSox respectively. The dye treated cells were subjected to flow cytometry and microscopic analysis. To measure the ROS levels after extraneous stress, cells from the mid log phase were treated with 1 mM H2O2. The treated cells were washed with 1X PBS and stained with the respective dyes.
4.7 Mitophagy induction
All the indicated strains were tagged with GFP at the C-terminus of mitochondrial OM45. The strains were then subjected to growth in YP-dextrose media till the mid-log phase. These cells were shifted to grow in YP-glycerol media for the indicated time points at the permissive temperature of 30 °C. Lysates were collected and subjected to Western blotting. Using the same strategy, cells were subjected to microscopic analysis, and the vacuolar localization of processed OM45-GFP was detected.
4.8 Statistical analysis
All statistical analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism6.0 software. Error bars represent Standard deviation (S.D) derived from at least three biological replicates. One-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple comparison test was used for significance analysis. Asterisks used in the figures represent the following significance values: *, p ≤ 0.05; **, p ≤ 0.01; ***, p ≤ 0.001; ****, p ≤ 0.0001; ns, not significant. Student t-test was performed for significance analysis with respect to WT (**, p ≤ 0.05).
List of primers used
List of strains used
Funding
This work was supported by DST-SERB (Grant File No. CRG/2018/001988) and Department of Biotechnology (DBT-IISC Partnership Program Phase-II, No. BT/PR27952/IN/22/21/2018) and DST-FIST Programme Phase III (No. SR/FST/LSII-045/2016(G) (to P.D.S). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Author contribution
Conceptualization: Sananda Biswas, Patrick D’Silva. Data curation: Sananda Biswas, Patrick D’Silva. Formal analysis: Sananda Biswas, Patrick D’Silva. Investigation: Sananda Biswas. Methodology: Sananda Biswas. Project administration: Patrick D’Silva. Supervision: Patrick D’Silva. Validation: Sananda Biswas, Patrick D’Silva. Visualization: Sananda Biswas, Patrick D’Silva. Writing – original draft: Sananda Biswas. Writing – review & editing: Sananda Biswas, Patrick D’Silva.
Competing interest
The authors declare that no competing interests exist.
Supporting information legend
Supplementary Fig. 1: Ubp2 exclusively shows genetic interaction with cells having combinatorial deletion of Hsp31 and Hsp34.Phenotypic assessment of the indicated strains at permissive temperature(30°C) and non permissive temperature(24°C and 37°C).
Supplementary Fig. 2: Ubp2 is expressed variably as a function of growth in WT cells. WT and Δ31Δ34 were tagged with HA at the C-terminus of Ubp2 and grown in dextrose-containing media until mid-log phase(6h) and late-log phase (12h). Lysates extracted from the cells were checked for differences in Ubp2 expression by Western blotting.
Supplementary Fig. 3: Ubp2 deletion in Δ31 and Δ34 leads to the accumulation of fragmented mitochondria. Analysis of mitochondrial structures in the indicated strains transformed with mTS-mCherry construct and visualized under fluorescence microscope at 100X magnification.
Supplementary Fig. 4: Dnm1 levels remain unaltered. WT, Δubp2, Δ31Δ34, Δ31Δ34Δubp2 were tagged with HA at the C-terminus of Dnm1 and lysates were subjected to Western blotting to check for difference in expression.
Acknowledgements
Fzo1 antibody is a kind gift from Prof. Mafalda Escobar-Henriques, Centre for Molecular Medicine, Cologne,Germany. Poly ubiquitin-specific antibody is a kind gift from Prof. Utpal Nath, Indian Institute of Science, Bengaluru.We thank the Flow Cytometry facility of the Indian Institute of Science,Bengaluru. We thank Dr. Saravanan Palani, Indian Institute of Science, Bengaluru for the microscopy facility.