Abstract
Embryos undergo pre-gastrulation cleavage cycles to generate a critical cell mass before transitioning to morphogenesis. The molecular underpinnings of this transition have traditionally centered on zygotic chromatin remodeling and genome activation1,2, as their repression can prevent downstream processes of differentiation and organogenesis. Despite precedents that oxygen depletion can similarly suspend development in early embryos3–6, hinting at a pivotal role for oxygen metabolism in this transition, whether there is a bona fide chemical switch that licenses the onset of morphogenesis remains unknown. Here we discover that a mitochondrial oxidant acts as a metabolic switch to license the onset of animal morphogenesis. Concomitant with the instatement of mitochondrial membrane potential, we found a burst-like accumulation of mitochondrial superoxide (O2-) during fly blastoderm formation. In vivo chemistry experiments revealed that an electron leak from site IIIQo at ETC Complex III is responsible for O2- production. Importantly, depleting mitochondrial O2- fully mimics anoxic conditions and, like anoxia, induces suspended animation prior to morphogenesis, but not after. Specifically, H2O2, and not ONOO-, NO, or HO•, can single-handedly account for this mtROS-based response. We demonstrate that depleting mitochondrial O2- similarly prevents the onset of morphogenetic events in vertebrate embryos and ichthyosporea, close relatives of animals. We postulate that such redox-based metabolic licensing of morphogenesis is an ancient trait of holozoans that couples the availability of oxygen to development, conserved from early-diverging animal relatives to vertebrates.
Main
Animal embryogenesis starts with proliferative cleavage cycles to build a foundational cell mass in preparation for transitioning to differentiation and organogenesis – a milestone developmental switch that defines the onset of morphogenesis. Seminal genetic approaches paved the way to dissecting the molecular underpinnings of this transition process7,8, revealing a set of zygotic molecules produced upon embryonic genome activation. Largely involved in chromatin remodeling and cytoskeletal organization, these factors help establish cell adhesion and polarity at the basis of body patterning and axis-determination9–11. As such, a framework centering on zygotic genome activation has emerged for the morphogenetic licensing of early development.
Recent germline-based maternal effect studies, however, paint a more complex picture for the upstream control of this transition, as they reveal an unexpected set of additional gene products related to mitochondrial metabolism, such as protein import12, nucleoid maintenance13, the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle14,15 and oxidative phosphorylation16. Although several mitochondria-associated enzymes have been found to gate chromatin remodeling and zygotic genome activation at the onset of morphogenesis17,18, exact upstream signals and roles that the mitochondrial metabolism plays in this transition remain largely unknown. Despite reports that such maternal effect mutants can halt development prior to morphogenesis14,16, whether there is a bona fide metabolic switch that licenses this transition, and if so, how this is achieved chemically remains unclear.
A mitochondrial ROS burst at the onset of morphogenesis
Classic studies have demonstrated that the absence of oxygen (anoxia) can suspend blastula formation in many animals, from brine shrimps4,19 to fishes5,20, from worms6,21 to fruit flies3. Dubbed suspended animation, such an early embryonic response to oxygen deprivation has traditionally been attributed to its likely consumption of oxygen for oxidative phosphorylation, as needed to generate ATP in mitochondria. Paradoxically, however, supplying ATP into early embryos incapable of electron transport chain (ETC) or TCA fails to rescue suspended animation22,23. Supporting this notion, other works have demonstrated that it is primarily glycolysis that meets the energetic demands of early development in pre-gastrulation invertebrate24,25 and vertebrate embryos26–29. Together, these results hint at a role for oxygen at the onset of morphogenesis that extends beyond its canonical use in oxidative phosphorylation.
Besides their role in ATP production, mitochondria act as the major source of reactive oxygen species (ROS). As this is another fundamental oxygen-dependent process that serves to signal physiological processes30,31, we began by exploring this possibility in Drosophila embryogenesis (Figs. 1 and 2). Just as in vertebrates20, reaerating anoxic fly embryos can rescue suspended animation without lethality only after, but not before, the onset of morphogenesis3. Since this highlights an indispensable role for oxygen during blastoderm formation, we first monitored mitochondrial membrane potential (ΔΨm) in living blastoderms injected with tetramethylrhodamine ethyl ester perchlorate (TMRE) (Fig. 1a). Consistent with the initiation of oxidative phosphorylation at the onset of morphogenesis24,26–29, mitochondria gradually instated their ΔΨm starting largely from cycle 12 during blastoderm formation and plateauing in cycle 14 (Fig. 1b). Surprisingly, however, in embryos treated with CellROX – a probe approximating superoxide (O2-) formation32 – we also observed a burst of ROS production that accompanies ΔΨm instatement at the onset of morphogenesis (Fig. 2a,b).
Excess ROS production can damage mitochondrial motility33 and dynamics34, leading to their elimination by fragmentation and mitophagy35. Given that embryos have an inherent capacity to induce mitophagy – as observed in allophagy during paternal mitochondrial elimination36–38 – we tested whether the ROS burst during blastoderm formation could lead to similar mitochondrial responses. In embryos expressing Tom20-mCherry (a mitochondrial outer membrane marker; Supplementary Video 1), we found that the blastoderm mitochondria are dynamic and go through fission/fusion (Fig. 1c) despite the ROS burst and their relatively small sizes (Extended Data Fig. 1a). Just as their counterparts in somatic tissues39, mitochondrial fission-fusion cycles appeared to be in sync with the progression of the cell cycle (Fig. 1d and Extended Data Fig. 1b,c), in which mitochondria mostly fuse during interphase and go under fission during mitosis. We found that fusing mitochondria was on average smaller than those that undergo fission (Extended Data Fig. 1a,d), implicating that the regulatory mechanisms responsible for mitochondrial size and morphology homeostasis40 are intact in these embryos. Based on previously established ultrastructure guidelines (see Methods), we also confirmed these by electron microscopy, examining signatures of mitochondrial morphology in sectioned wild-type embryos (Fig. 1e-h). Since mitochondria were homogenously spread across the apico-basal axis (Fig. 1g), we concluded that mitochondrial motility continues to serve its function41 of homogenously distributing these organelles at this stage of development. As evident from most autophagosomes filled with undigested lipids in the form of autolysosomes (Fig. 1f; see Methods), we observed active autophagy during fly blastoderm formation, yet never found any instances of mitophagy (Fig. 1h).
Given that blastoderm mitochondria are dynamic and appear to be regulated normally, these results suggested that the burst of ROS production (Fig. 2a,b) is unlikely to be an inadvertent consequence of mitochondrial activation at this stage of development. As such, we next aimed to identify the exact sources of embryonic ROS, enabling us to investigate its potential role at the onset of morphogenesis.
Mitochondrial Complex III mediates the ROS production at the onset of morphogenesis
Injecting CellROX into embryos expressing Tom20-GFP, we found that most ROS production appears to co-localize with mitochondria (Extended Data Fig. 2a,b). To directly test whether mitochondria can account for embryonic ROS production, we examined CellROX in embryos pre-treated with MitoTEMPO, a mitochondria-targeted antioxidant that specifically scavenges O2- (Fig. 2c). We found that mitochondria can indeed fully account for the CellROX signal we observe in these embryos (Fig. 2d,e and Extended Data Fig. 3a,b).
Mitochondrial O2- is generated by electrons (e-) prematurely leaking from e- carriers through ETC and reacting with oxygen. Although there are at least eleven reported sites of leak in mitochondria42, growing evidence highlights the ubiquinone-reducing site of Complex I (site IQ) and the ubiquinol-oxidizing site of Complex III (site IIIQo) as the primary leak sources for O2- as relevant to physiology43,44 (Fig. 2c). To test whether e- leak from ETC can account for the mitochondrial O2- production, we leveraged a new class of small molecule suppressors that selectively eliminate O2- production by Complex I at site IQ (S1QEL1.1) and Complex III at site IIIQo (S3QEL2) without affecting the e- transfer or altering oxidative phosphorylation45,46 (Fig. 2c). Although targeting e- leak at Complex I appeared to mildly influence O2- production in mitochondria, the effect was not statistically significant (Fig. 2d,e and Extended Data Fig. 3c). Targeting the e- leak at Complex III, however, completely abolished mitochondrial O2- production and fully mimicked the results with MitoTEMPO treatments (Fig. 2d,e and Extended Data Fig. 3b,d). Together, these results indicate that e- leak at Complex III site IIIQo is the primary source of mitochondrial O2- at the onset of fly morphogenesis.
Complex III-mediated ROS production acts as a metabolic switch to license the onset of morphogenesis
Even a normally functioning ETC can leak electrons and produce O2- at basal levels, so the mitochondrial O2- that we observe (Fig. 2a and Extended Data Fig. 2 and 3) could simply be a byproduct of ETC activation. Since ROS formation is restricted by oxygen availability, we sought to test whether preventing O2- production would functionally mimic the suspended animation induced by anoxia during blastoderm formation3 (Fig. 2f). Remarkably, both scavenging mitochondrial O2- altogether and eliminating e- leak specifically at Complex III (site IIIQo) suspended embryogenesis by a developmental arrest with chromatin condensed in a Rabl-like configuration – the exact cytological response that anoxia uniquely elicits during the embryogenesis of flies3 and other invertebrates47 (Fig. 2f and Extended Data Fig. 4; see how this arrest is robust even to exogenous perturbations in Supplementary Video 2). Reminiscent of the switch-like viability difference of anoxic embryos with reference to the onset of morphogenesis3,20, both types of O2- elimination induced suspended animation only during the blastoderm formation (nuclear cycles 11-13) preceding the onset of morphogenesis, but not after (cycle 14) (Fig. 2f,g and Extended Data Fig. 4).
Suspended animation of anoxic embryos necessitates a halt to the nuclear division cycle3,5,6 – just as we also find is the case for oxidant-depleted embryos (Fig. 2f and Supplementary Video 2). Although redox-based activation of cell cycle regulators48,49 can explain how such a nuclear arrest can be achieved, emerging evidence indicates that aspects of cytoplasmic organization, divisions and even differentiation can occur autonomously of the mitotic CDK/cyclin complexes and nuclear divisions in early development50–55. Since lack of oxidant signaling can similarly impair myosin recruitment to plasma membrane56–58 and actin polymerization59,60 – two key drivers of cortical contractility during gastrulation – we tested whether eliminating O2- production prior to morphogenesis can also impair components of cortical contractility beyond a nuclear cycle arrest. To this end, we examined the behavior of non-muscle myosin II (by MRLC-GFP) and actin (by Moe-ABD-GFP) upon suspended animation. We found that myosin recruitment to the plasma membrane and cortical actin organization were abolished in a strikingly all-or-none manner (Extended Data Fig. 5), directly mimicking the inhibition of Rho-kinase activity and actin polymerization in these embryos53. As such, distinguishing it from a canonical cell cycle arrest that cannot prevent cortical organization needed for gastrulation54,61, eliminating O2- during blastoderm formation prevents progression into morphogenesis in part by halting cortical organization.
Together, these results demonstrate that mitochondrial Complex III-mediated ROS production in early embryos normally acts as a ‘metabolic switch’ to license the onset of fly morphogenesis.
HO•, NO or ONOO- cannot account for the mtROS-based switch
O2- molecules are the most upstream ROS produced in mitochondria. However, these oxidants are short-lived62 (as minimally as t1/2 of milliseconds), as they are almost simultaneously converted to more stable oxygen and nitrogen species upon their production (Fig. 3a). Since a capacity to act as a signaling molecule would require stability to diffuse longer distances, we conjectured that a downstream oxidant species must act as a key signal for the mtROS-based switch in embryos. We first investigated hydroxyl radicals (HO•) (Fig. 3a). To test whether their depletion can induce the Rabl-like phenotype, we leveraged dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), an organosulfur compound that – at 5×10-2 to 1M in vitro – fully scavenges HO• 63,64. Factoring in ∼20x dilution upon microinjections, we examined embryos expressing fluorescent His2Av (chromatin) using a dilution series of DMSO with a maximum needle concentration at 14M (Extended Data Fig. 6a-d). As an injection control, we used water to account for their injection-induced repercussions (e.g., telophase defects and chromosome damages). Fortuitously, the DMSO experiments also acted as a vehicle control per its use as a solvent in our experiments to eliminate mitochondrial O2- production (Extended Data Fig. 6e-g). Across the dilution series, and even at the highest possible [DMSO], we found that majority of the embryos and their nuclei appeared relatively normal (Extended Data Fig. 6a-d), and rest of the phenotypes largely overlapped with the defects observed by the injection procedure itself with water (Extended Data Fig. 6b).
As a potent hygroscopic agent inducing dehydration near lipid membrane surfaces65, DMSO also induced shrinking of nuclei, making them appear as though they are desiccated. Interestingly, early embryos appeared particularly vulnerable to such dehydration (Extended Data Fig. 6d). We currently do not know the exact reasons for this vulnerability, but because early embryos are concentrated with unusual amounts of maternally deposited lipids and carbohydrates25,66,67, they may be particularly sensitive to dehydration. Indeed, we never observed this phenomenon during water injections (Extended Data Fig. 6a,b), even when performed systematically across different cycles (Extended Data Fig. 8f). Meanwhile, we almost never encountered a Rabl-like phenotype during our DMSO experiments (n=92 embryos) – except for one embryo, which accounts for only ∼2% of the total number of injections even at the highest possible [DMSO]. We ascribe this outlier to the vast feedback networks that regulate redox chemistry in vivo: depleting one type of free radical can influence the production of another, as exemplified by the case of O2- molecules vide infra (Extended Data Figs. 7 and 8). Together, these suggested that HO• is unlikely to account for the mtROS-based switch at the onset of morphogenesis.
We next tested the involvement of nitric oxide (NO) and peroxynitrite (ONOO-), two nitrogen species that are intricately linked with mitochondrial ROS metabolism69 (Fig. 3a and Extended Data Fig. 7a). Although, NO signaling has been previously studied in fly embryos using exogenous supplement of its donors22 (e.g., S-Nitroso-N-acetylpenicillamine), whether it is generated endogenously in this system remains unknown. Since ONOO- is produced by the reaction of NO and O2-, we first probed ONOO- with a selective fluorescent probe conjugated to a hydrazide group70, acting also as a simultaneous indicator for the presence of endogenous NO (Extended Data Fig. 7a). Consistent with its affinity to induce lipid peroxidation and to oxidize low-density lipoproteins71,72, we found that endogenous ONOO- was largely associated with yolk granules in the embryo interior (basal) and appeared diffusely in the blastoderm cytosol (apical) (Extended Data Fig. 7b). Interestingly, the chromatin in embryos injected with the ONOO- fluorescent probe occasionally displayed the Rabl-like phenotype (Extended Data Fig. 8a,b). As this probe fluoresces by reacting with ONOO- molecules (Extended Data Fig. 7a), we suspected that diminishing ONOO- levels by this reaction may trigger suspended animation. However, it is also possible that such prolonged ONOO- depletion could impair feedback mechanisms that normally prevent excess NO production via the availability of ONOO- itself72, resulting in an amplified sink of O2- due to its increased consumption by NO. To resolve between these possibilities, we reasoned to prevent ONOO- formation by scavenging NO, as the latter’s production is a limiting factor for the former independently of O2- (see Extended Data Fig. 7a). Leveraging a widely used NO scavenger to perturb ONOO- production (Extended Data Figs. 7c,d), we found that this is indeed the case: neither decreasing ONOO- levels nor diminishing NO is sufficient to trigger the Rabl-like phenotype in a significant way (Extended Data Fig. 8c-f).
In summary, our experiments suggested that – like the HO• – depleting NO and ONOO- alone cannot account for the Rabl-like phenotype. These results are also consistent with the dispensability of nitric oxide synthase for Drosophila development73. Instead, another oxidant that stem from O2- must be responsible for the mtROS-based switch at the onset of morphogenesis.
H2O2 molecules are single-handedly necessary and sufficient for the mtROS-based switch
We finally investigated hydrogen peroxide (H2O2). First, we assessed whether the mitochondrial O2- production is accompanied by H2O2 formation during blastoderm formation, as would be expected from their simultaneous dismutation by superoxide dismutase (Extended Data Fig. 9a). Using MitoPY1, a boronate-based probe that fluoresces upon its selective reaction with H2O2 in mitochondria75, we found that this is indeed the case (Extended Data Fig. 9b,c). Surprisingly, the injected embryos occasionally displayed the Rabl-like phenotype (Extended Data Fig. 9d,e). As MitoPY1 fluoresces by reacting with H2O2 molecules and may lead to its partial depletion (Extended Data Fig. 9a), we sought to test whether a more complete depletion of H2O2 by its catalysis can consistently suspend embryogenesis. As catalase breaks down H2O2 into water and oxygen (Fig. 3a), we administrated this oxidoreductase (purified from bovine liver) and examined its effects in embryos expressing His2Av-GFP. Remarkably, the catalytic decomposition of H2O2 halted embryonic development in a Rabl-like arrest (Fig. 3b,c). As such, we conclude that H2O2 production is necessary to satisfy the mtROS-based switch.
To test whether H2O2 can be sufficient for the mtROS-based switch, we sought to perform “rescue” experiments. Upon a cumulative depletion of mitochondrial ROS, we asked whether adding back only H2O2 could release embryos from suspended animation. By taking advantage of H2O2’s widely observed karyotypic toxicity at supraphysiological concentrations76–79, we first determined a range of add-back [H2O2] needed in vivo. Across a dilution series starting with off-the-shelf concentration at 9.8M, we examined the effects of H2O2 in embryos that express His2Av-GFP (Extended Data Fig. 10). As expected, a palette of karyotype damages ensued across the dilution series (Extended Data Fig. 10a; see Methods for the phenotype nuances), which gradually declined as [H2O2] was lowered (Extended Data Fig. 10b). With water injection-induced damages as the benchmark, we established a “physiological” range for the add-back [H2O2] needed for our prospective rescue experiments (Fig. 3d). Next, we pre-treated blastoderm-stage embryos with MitoTEMPO to induce suspended animation (Fig. 3e). We then attempted to rescue the suspended embryos by adding back H2O2 (Fig. 3e,f). Remarkably, we achieved a complete rescue in 40% of our trials at a concentration of 4.9×10-10 M (Fig. 3e,g and Supplementary Video 3; dubbed ‘full’ rescue), in which chromatin decondensed from the Rabl-like configuration and resumed its mitotic progression, albeit with telophase errors (Supplementary Video 3). As a control, we added back water and did not observe a rescue (Fig. 3f and Extended Data Fig. 11d,e).
Within the concentration range of 4.9×10-11 to 9.8×10-10 M, resupplying H2O2 also led to an incomplete rescue phenotype (dubbed ‘partial rescue’), in which chromatin decondensed yet did not resume the cell cycle (Fig. 3e,g and Supplementary Video 4). Surprisingly, at concentration ranges closer to supraphysiological conditions, adding back H2O2 did not induce either of the rescue phenotypes (Fig. 3e,f and Supplementary Video 2). We hypothesize that chromatin damages induced by excess H2O2 may also impair nuclear ability to go through the mitotic cycle, hence overriding H2O2’s ability to fully rescue suspended animation.
Could suspended animation in oxidant-depleted embryos somehow stem from a loss of overall capacity to generate ATP? We tested this possibility by mimicking the above experiments for H2O2, but by adding back ATP. It is well established that excess ATP chelates Mg+279–81 – a divalent cation critical for the dynamic instability of microtubules83–85, hence required for proper spindle assembly and chromosome segregation. As such, we aimed to determine an optimal add-back concentration by examining the karyotypic toxicity of ATP at 0.5–5mM, the homeostatic range of intracellular ATP86 (Extended Data Fig. 11). Accounting for ∼20x dilution from a maximum needle concentration at 100mM (i.e., ∼5mM effective conc.), ATP injections – even across this homeostatic range – were largely associated with a series of mitotic defects (Extended Data Fig. 11a). Only near the range minima (∼0.6mM effective conc.), the injected embryos developed normally (Extended Data Fig. 11b,c). Using this concentration, we attempted to rescue MitoTEMPO-treated embryos from suspended animation with ATP, but to no avail (Extended Data Fig. 11d,e). Like previous studies that failed to rescue early embryos with impaired of ETC or TCA using ATP22,23, we conclude that the same holds true for suspended animation triggered by oxidant depletion, even at the highest tolerable [ATP] supplement.
Collectively, these results demonstrate that H2O2 is necessary and sufficient for the mtROS-based switch at the onset of morphogenesis. Since simply decondensing chromatin is not sufficient to enable mitotic cycling (Fig. 3e and Supplementary Video 4), H2O2’s role to satisfy the mtROS- based switch in oxidant-depleted embryos appears at least two-fold: first by releasing chromatin from its Rabl-like configuration, then by permitting cell cycle progression. These findings highlight the complexity of the mtROS-based switch, paving the way towards identifying the genetic and biochemical basis of metabolic licensing in early animal development.
mtROS-based oxidant switch is conserved from animal relatives to vertebrates
Oxygen depletion-induced suspended animation is a widely conserved phenomenon in the early embryogenesis of many animals3–6,19 (Fig. 4a). Such capacity to induce hypometabolism may possibly be a common feature in the early life cycles of opisthokonts more generally, as oxygen depletion can suspend even the sporulation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae87. Thus, we sought to explore whether the mtROS-based switch that we observe at the onset of early invertebrate development could be a hallmark of licensing morphogenesis metabolically across holozoans.
To test the involvement of an mtROS-based switch at the onset of vertebrate morphogenesis, we used early Danio rerio (zebrafish) embryos – a model vertebrate for oxygen depletion studies5,20,88. Using MitoTEMPO to scavenge mitochondrial O2-, we examined the progression towards blastula formation. Remarkably, embryos injected at the 1-cell stage suspended their cell cycles only after 1k cell stage (around oblong-sphere stages) during blastula formation prior to the onset of morphogenesis (Fig. 4b-e, Extended Data Fig. 12, and Supplementary Video 5). Just as in fly embryos (Extended Data Fig. 4), we examined whether preventing O2- production in fish embryos would phenotypically mimic the suspended animation induced by oxygen depletion in this system5. As embodied by a chromatin condensation phenotype in a pre-mitotic/prophase arrest5, we found that this is indeed the case (Extended Data Fig. 12).
Inspired by the strict requirement for oxygen in fungal sporulation87 (Fig. 4a), we next explored how widely such an mtROS-based switch could be conserved across holozans. To this end, we examined ichthyosporeans, protists positioned between animals and fungi, and considered among the closest relatives of animals with choanoflagellates and filastereans. Leading to the emergence of animals, ichthyosporeans are speculated as key species towards the evolution of embryogenesis89,90. Under active scrutiny, this is not least because their morphogenesis succeeds the formation of a multicellular palintomic90,91, or multinucleate coenocytic92,93, epithelial structure that exhibits similarities and behaves like the animal blastulae and blastoderms respectively93,94. In Sphaeroforma arctica, a coenocytic ichthyosporean, the assembly of a blastoderm-like structure is followed by a cellularization-based morphogenesis event92 (Extended Data Fig. 13) – reminiscent of fly embryos89. As such, we tested whether eliminating mitochondrial O2- influences the progression of an initially single-celled S. arctica to its transient multicellular layer before its redispersal (Fig. 4f). Although S. arctica cultured in medium containing MitoTEMPO grew very similarly to their control counterpart, they strikingly suspended development at the onset of morphogenesis immediately prior to cellularization (Fig. 4g-j and Supplementary Video 6). Unlike fishes and flies, however, the chromatin of S. arctica was not associated with a particular chromosome condensation phenotype during suspended animation (Fig. 4h), even when we assessed chromatin configuration by ultrastructure expansion microscopy (Fig. 4k). Given that S. arctica lack proteins such as BAF and KASH critical for tethering chromatin to the nuclear envelope90, these results hint at the emergence of novel cytological features associated with suspended animation towards the evolution of metazoans.
Together, the exceptional similarities we observe among oxidant-depleted ichthyosporeans and the embryos of flies and fishes compel us to postulate that an mtROS-based metabolic licensing of morphogenesis is an ancient trait of holozoans, from close animal relatives to vertebrates.
Discussion
Despite early proposals by pioneers Jacques Loeb and Joseph Needham on the possibility of a chemical basis for licensing morphogenesis95,96, whether there is a bona fide switch that controls this in development, and if so, how it could be achieved molecularly remain unknown. Here we discover in flies that mitochondrial Complex III-mediated ROS production acts as a metabolic switch to license the onset of morphogenesis. Our findings from fishes and close relatives of animals suggest the striking possibility of a broad conservation of this switch across holozoans.
By elucidating the function of oxygen in early embryogenesis, evidence of an mtROS-based switch licensing morphogenesis resolves several paradoxes of classic studies that established the indispensability of oxygen in animal development. For instance, anoxia-induced suspended animation during blastoderm formation has been ascribed to a hypometabolic state that emerges from perturbing mitochondrial ATP production3. Yet, it has remained enigmatic why halting oxidative phosphorylation (e.g. by hypoxia22 or mutations against the ATP synthase machinery16) fails to trigger the Rabl-like arrest observed under anoxic conditions. In fact, these perturbations trigger a metaphase arrest and/or defects associated with chromosome segregation16,22, consistent with a partial manipulation of ATP levels as the same studies report16,22 and as found in our experiments (Extended Data Fig. 11). Combined with reports of glycolysis as the primary energy source in pre-gastrulation invertebrate24,25 and vertebrate embryos26–29, our results attribute a new role for oxygen prior to the onset of morphogenesis. This can also explain, at least in part, why providing embryos incapable of ETC22 or TCA23 with ATP is not sufficient to rescue suspended development. As ΔΨm fully reinstates only by cycle 13-to-14 transition in fly embryos (Fig. 1a,b), our results may also explain why maternal effect mutations against the ATP synthase machinery can ramify a phenotype only by these cycles during fly development16. Furthermore, as both mitochondrial ATP and ROS production source electrons from ETC, our results may provide a new framework for interpreting why ETC inhibition might prevent developmental progression at similar stages of animal embryogenesis more generally97.
To this end, recent studies have demonstrated that oocytes, which are under ‘respiratory quiescence’, become more oxidative upon fertilization in various animals98–100. An activity-based profiling of H2O2-modified cysteines has revealed that reactive thiols are largely enriched in proteins associated with mitotic processes during fly oocyte-to-embryo transition99. However, it remains unclear whether such enrichment simply reflects the high concentration of molecules involved in cell cycle control as essential in embryogenesis. It is unknown whether such chemistry could converge on a bona fide decision-making mechanism that influences embryonic fate, especially before it switches from a highly proliferative to a differentiating state at the onset of morphogenesis. We postulate that the conserved mtROS-based switch identified here could accomplish this by monitoring the redox status of embryos in a window preceding morphogenesis. As oxidants regulate key morphogenetic pathways involving PI3K/Akt, MAPKs, GPCRs and JNK signaling101, the development could be suspended until – and if at all – a sufficient redox capacity is achieved to promote morphogenesis.
Our work demonstrates in flies that limiting H2O2 levels can single-handedly regulate entry into such suspended animation by seizing embryonic contractility beyond a simple cell-cycle arrest. Such response is also embodied in zebrafish embryos, in which most cytoplasmic motion appears to be halted upon oxidant depletion (Fig. 4b and Supplementary Video 5), just as observed with anoxia-induced suspended animation in these embryos5. Readily hinted at by other recent studies102,103, these results may also provide a new rationale for why oocytes suppress ROS production: that H2O2 may otherwise act as an upstream chemical cue licensing morphogenesis. Further work is required to test whether this is mutually exclusive with the possibility of ROS as deteriorating agents in oocytes, as proposed before100.
What could sense declining H2O2 levels at the basis of an mtROS-based switch prior to morphogenesis? Unlike mechanisms that monitor oxidative stress, molecular mechanisms for sensing reductive stress are only beginning to be recognized104,105 and remain largely unexplored in animal development106. Although the suspended animation phenotype we observe here is essentially the same as that observed under anoxia conditions, mechanisms that monitor declining H2O2 levels are unlikely to converge on canonical oxygen sensors. Indeed, flies homozygous null for sima (Drosophila HIF-1α) are viable and fertile in normoxia107, and even the anoxia-response itself is independent of HIF-1α as demonstrated in worm embryos6. These suggest that a yet-to-be-identified mechanism in development must respond to declining H2O2 levels upon a wholesale depletion of either oxygen or oxidants.
We still do not know the conditions that activate this switch prior to the onset of morphogenesis and deactivate it thereafter. However, our study establishes the missing link between oxygen and morphogenetic licensing, invigorating future work to fully characterize this relationship. For instance, since O2- molecules are detectable during blastoderm formation (Fig. 2a,b) at levels above basal production in normally functioning mitochondria, it is plausible that the ETC might be partially uncoupled prior to morphogenesis. A recent study reporting ETC uncoupling to gate the Spemann organizer in frogs attests to this possibility in a developmental setting108. In this regard, it is possible that cytoplasmic conditions favoring ETC uncoupling may help define when the mtROS switch can be active prior to morphogenesis.
By revealing a direct link between the early developmental utility of oxygen and an mtROS-based switch that controls morphogenetic commitment, our findings establish a mechanistic basis for uncovering the metabolic licensing of early embryogenesis. Further genetic and chemical studies dissecting the targets of such an mtROS-based response, and how declining H2O2 levels can be monitored in embryos, will pave the way for the molecular framework underlying this essential metabolic switch that controls the onset of animal morphogenesis.
Author contributions
This study was conceptualised by K.M.T. and M.G.A. Investigation was done by U.K., F.D.R., S.J.P., L-E.J., O.D., K.M. and M.G.A. Data were analysed by U.K., F.D.R., S.J.P., M.O., L-E.J., O.D. and M.G.A. Methodology was developed by U.K., F.D.R., S.J.P., L-E.J., O.D., K.M. and M.G.A. Project was administrated by M.G.A. Resources were shared/made by U.K., F.D.R., S.J.P., M.O., K.M.T., L-E.J., O.D., K.M. and M.G.A. Software work was carried out by U.K., F.D.R., S.J.P., O.D. and M.G.A. Overall supervision was done by M.G.A. Validation experiments/analyses were carried out by U.K., F.D.R., S.J.P. and M.G.A. The main version of this manuscript was drafted by U.K., F.D.R., S.J.P. and M.G.A. with significant input from all authors. Finally, all authors reviewed and edited the manuscript.
Competing interests
Authors declare no competing interests for this study.
Data and material availability
All microscopy data and experimental materials are available from the corresponding author upon request.
Methods
D. melanogaster husbandry, embryo collection, and microinjections
Flies were kept at a 25°C incubator in culture medium (7.5% molasses, 1.01% agar, 1.4% agar, 5.6% cornmeal, 0.75% tegosept, 0.23% propionic acid, 0.04% phosphoric acid) in vials or bottles, as described previously109. All crosses were performed at room temperature and maintained at 25°C, unless mentioned otherwise. Following fly stocks were used in this study: OregonR wild type; His2Av-GFP (FBal0104781); His2Av-mRFP (FBst00233650); MRLC-GFP (FBal0221190); (sqh)-Moe-ABD-GFP (gift from D. Kiehart); UAS-Tom20-(SNAP)-GFP-(HA) (FBst0084254); UAS-Tom20-mCherry (gift from P.H. O’Farrell); V32-Gal4 (FBtp0009293); His2Av-mCer (FBst0091659).
For embryo collections, adult female flies were maintained in cages with juice plates (40% cranberry-raspberry juice containing 2% sucrose and 1.8% agar) supplemented with a droplet of yeast paste. To promote egg-laying and discard of over-night embryos, the cages were treated with a shedder plate for an hour prior to the embryo collection. Fresh juice plates were swapped with the shedder plate and incubated for 20 minutes at 25°C. The embryos were aged for an extra 45-50 minutes to aim for injections at nuclear cycle 9-11. Depending on the developmental cycle of interest, the incubation times varied. After the incubation period, embryos were dechorionated on a clear double-sided tape by manually removing the chorion using a needle and aligning them through a strip of glue on 35-mm MatTek glass-bottom petri dishes with a 14mm microwell, as described previously110. After desiccation at 25°C for 6 min, the embryos were covered with Grade H10S Voltalef oil (Arkema), followed by injections of drugs, dyes, purified enzymes or metabolites.
Microinjections were performed using Sutter Instrument borosilicate glass capillary tubes (of 1.2mm and 0.9 mm outer and inner diameters respectively). The capillaries were pulled on a P-87 micropipette puller at heat (670), pull (60), velocity (80), and time (190). Post-injection incubation times were 10 mins, except for purified enzymes injected and incubated 1h prior to imaging at desired cycles. Double injection experiments were performed by a first injection followed by a 10min incubation at 25°C, then a second injection aiming at the exact injection site (marked by the previous injection’s liquid displacement) followed by another 10min incubation at 25°C.
D. rerio husbandry, embryo collections, and microinjections
Wild-type NHGRI-1 fish111 were bred and maintained using standard procedures112. Embryos were obtained by natural spawning and staged as previously described113. The researcher (Li-En Jao) was approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee, Office of Animal Welfare Assurance, University of California, Davis.
Microinjection of zebrafish embryos was performed as previously described114. Briefly, thin wall glass capillaries (World Precision Instruments, #TW100F-4) were pulled on a P-87 micropipette puller. Injections were performed with an air injection apparatus (Pneumatic MPPI-2 Pressure Injector). Injected volume was calibrated with a microruler. Approximately 2–3nl of an injection mix containing the drug or DMSO along with 48 μM 5-610CP-Hoechst115 was injected into the yolk of 1-cell stage embryos. Injected embryos were raised at 28.5°C until 512–1k cell stage before the major wave of zygotic genome activation1. The embryos were then manually dechorionated and mounted in 0.8% low-melt agarose with the dorsal side down in 35-mm glass-bottom dishes (MatTek Corp., P35G-1.5-10-C, or Cellvis, D35C4-20-1.5-N) for imaging.
S. arctica culturing and maintenance
Cryopreserved in 2012 at −80°C, a frozen culture of the ichthyosporean Sphaeroforma arctica (originally described by Jøstensen et al.116) has been recently diluted and maintained in Marine Broth 2216 (MB) (BD DifcoTM #279110 or Sigma-Aldrich #76448, 37.4 g/L) at 17°C.
S. arctica cultures were grown and synchronized as described previously91,94. Briefly, saturated cultures in MB were diluted into fresh medium at a low density (1:200 dilution of the saturated culture) and cultivated in rectangular canted neck cell culture flasks fitted with vented caps (Falcon, #353108) at 17°C in the absence of light, leading to the development of a synchronized culture. Saturated cultures of S. arctica were obtained after ∼3 weeks of growth in MB or ∼5 days of growth in MB diluted to 1/16 with artificial seawater (Instant Ocean, 36 g/L).
Administration of fluorescent probes, small molecules, purified enzymes and metabolites
Information on fluorescent probes
Following fluorescent probes with respective concentrations and solvents were microinjected into the indicated fly embryos: Tetramethylrhodamine (ThermoFisher, #T669) at 10µM in 100% DMSO into V32-Gal4; His2Av-Cer / UAS-Tom20-GFP embryos. CellROXTM Deep Red (ThermoFisher, #C10422) at 250 µM in milliQ water into either wild-type or V32-Gal4; His2Av-Cer / UAS-Tom20-GFP embryos. BioTracker Far-Red ONOO- live cell dye (Sigma-Aldrich, #SCT052) at 5mM in 100% DMSO into embryos expressing a) His2Av-GFP only, b) V32-Gal4; His2Av-Cer / UAS-Tom20-GFP embryos, or c) His2Av-GFP embryos pre-injected with Carboxy-PTIO potassium salt. MitoPY1 (Tocris, #4428) at 1mM in 100% DMSO into His2Av-mRFP embryos. 100% DMSO used in these experiments was at 14M stock concentration as acquired from Fisher Scientific (#D136-1).
Information on small molecules
Following small molecules with respective concentrations and solvents were microinjected into the indicated fly embryos: MitoTEMPO (Sigma-Aldrich, #SML0737) at 5-10mM in 100% DMSO into wild-type embryos pre-injected with CellROXTM Deep Red, or into embryos expressing a) His2Av-GFP, b) MRLC-GFP; His2Av-mRFP, or c) His2Av-mRFP; Moe-ABD-GFP. S1QEL1.1 (Cayman Chemicals, #20982) at 1mM in 10% DMSO into either His2Av-GFP embryos, or wild-type embryos pre-injected with CellROXTM Deep Red. S3QEL2 (Cayman Chemicals, #18556) at 1.5 mM in 75% DMSO into His2Av-GFP embryos, or wild-type embryos pre-injected with CellROXTM Deep Red. 100% DMSO was at 14M stock concentration as acquired from Sigma-Aldrich (#D8418). Carboxy-PTIO potassium salt (Sigma-Aldrich, #221) at 31.7mM in milliQ water into His2Av-GFP embryos. 100% DMSO used in these experiments was at 14M stock concentration as acquired from Fisher Scientific (#D136-1).
MitoTEMPO at 190-380mM in 100% DMSO was microinjected into zebrafish embryos bathed in 5mM MitoTEMPO (1-2% DMSO) throughout the experiments. S. arctica was cultured in 400µl media volumes containing 0.175mM effective concentration of MitoTEMPO.
Information on purified enzymes
Catalase from bovine liver (Sigma-Aldrich, #C1345) at 2,000-5,000 units/mg was dissolved in milliQ water to 0.5mg/ml and microinjected into fly embryos expressing His2Av-GFP.
Information on metabolites
Following metabolites with respective concentrations (at max.) and solvents were microinjected into the indicated fly embryos: 30% H2O2 (Fisher Scientific, #H325-500) at 9.8M in water into His2Av-GFP embryos. ATP (Fisher Scientific, #R0141) at 100mM in milliQ water into His2Av- GFP embryos. Starting with these max concentrations, serial dilutions and injections were performed for both metabolites to determine their effective physiological concentrations (see Fig. 3d and Extended Data Figs. 10 and 11). These solutions were then injected into His2Av-GFP embryos pre-injected with MitoTEMPO as part of the oxidant rescue experiments.
Light microscopy
D. melanogaster embryos were live imaged alternatingly on three different spinning-disk confocal systems: PerkinElmer Ultraview using an Olympus IX70 microscope using with a planApo 60x 1.40 NA oil immersion objective; VT-QLC100 (VisiTech International) using a Leica DM-IRB microscope with a HCX PL APO 63x 1.40 NA oil immersion objective; CSU10 Yokogawa using a Nikon Eclipse Ti-E microscope with a perfect focus system and a 60x 1.4NA oil immersion objective. On the former system, image acquisition was controlled via the Volocity 6.3 software (PerkinElmer), whereas the latter two via the µmanager software. Depending on the experiments, a stack of 10-20µm was acquired with a step size ranging 0.25-0.5µm at 10s, 30s or 1min intervals. To conduct intensity-based measurements, the laser power was pre-measured using a PM100D digital optical power meter (ThorLabs) prior to every experiment and was maintained at a nearly constant W within each experiment.
D. rerio embryos were live imaged using Dragonfly (Andor Technology, Oxford Instruments), a spinning-disk confocal system using a Leica DMi8 inverted microscope with a HC PL APO 40x 1.10 NA water immersion objective. Image acquisition was controlled by Fusion software (Andor Technology), and images were captured every min using an iXon Ultra 888 EMCCD or Zyla sCMOS camera (Andor Technology). Time-lapse imaging was performed inside a wrap-around environmental incubator (Okolab) set at 28.5°C.
S. arctica were live imaged using a fully motorized Nikon Ti2-E epifluorescence inverted microscope, equipped with a hardware autofocus PFS4 system, a Lumencor SOLA SMII illumination system, and a Hamamatsu ORCA-spark Digital CMOS camera. Imaging was facilitated using CFI Plan Fluor objectives, including 20x (0.50 NA), 40x air, and 60x oil (0.5-1.25 NA). To maintain a constant temperature of 17°C during live microscopy, a cooling/heating P Lab-Tek S1 insert (PeCon GmbH) connected to a Lauda Loop 100 circulating water bath was employed. Fixed and immunostained S. arctica were imaged using an upright Leica SP8 confocal microscope, equipped with an HC PL APO 40x 1.25 NA glycerol objective.
Electron microscopy
Sample preparation and electron microscopy experiments were done as previously described117,118. Briefly, wild-type embryos were collected at different developmental intervals and dechorionated by a 2min wash in 50% bleach. After a thorough rinse with water, the samples were transferred to the holder of a Balzer HPM 010 High Pressure Freezer, frozen and transferred to liquid nitrogen for long-term storage.
Samples were freeze-substituted in 2% osmium tetroxide plus 0.1% uranyl acetate in acetone for three days at −90°C. Subsequently, they were gradually warmed to 20°C over 6h and rinsed with 100% acetone for 3x 20min each. Infiltration with Epon-Araldite resin was carried out in a graded series of resin/acetone over 6 hours, then overnight in pure resin. Polymerization of resin was accomplished by heating at 60°C for 48 hours. 80nm sections were cut on a Reichert Ultracut E microtome and placed on copper grids.
Grids were stained with uranyl acetate for 5min and lead citrate for 2min. Using a Phillips CM10 electron microscope operating at 80kV, most micrographs were taken at a magnification of 15,500x. To generate the scale bar on EM micrographs in this paper, we took the diameter of microtubules (∼25nm) that are positioned longitudinally as our reference size.
Ultrastructural Expansion Microscopy (U-ExM)
U-ExM on S. arctica was conducted as described previously94,119. Initially, cells were fixed using a 4% formaldehyde (FA) solution in 250mM Sorbitol. After two washes with 1x PBS, fixed cells were resuspended in 20-30μl PBS. These cells were then allowed to adhere onto 12 mm poly-l- lysine-coated coverslips for 1h. Subsequently, they were anchored in an AA/FA solution (1% Acrylamide (AA)/0.7% Formaldehyde (FA)) overnight at 37°C. For gelation, a monomer solution consisting of 19% (wt/wt%) sodium acrylate (Chem Cruz, AKSci #7446-81-3), 10% (wt/wt%) Acrylamide (Sigma-Aldrich #A4058), and 0.1% (wt/wt%) N, N’- methylenbisacrylamide (Sigma-Aldrich #M1533) in 1xPBS was used. The gels were polymerized for 1h at 37°C in a humidified chamber. To facilitate denaturation, the gels were transferred to a denaturation buffer (50 mM Tris pH 9.0, 200 mM NaCl, 200 mM SDS, adjusted to pH 9.0) for 15min at room temperature, followed by incubation at 95°C for 1h. Following denaturation, expansion was achieved through multiple water exchanges, following the previously established procedure. Post-expansion, the diameter of the gel was measured to determine the expansion factor. In our U-ExM images, scale bars represent the actual size, which is adjusted for the gel expansion factor.
Sample fixation and immunostaining
S. arctica were fixed using 4% formaldehyde and 250mM Sorbitol for 20 min, then washed twice with PBS. For staining the nuclei, the cultures were allowed to settle for 15 min at room temperature before fixation. Subsequently, Hoechst 33342 (ThermoFisher, #62249) was added at 20 μM. Prior to imaging, fixed and stained S. arctica were concentrated and then mounted between a slide and a coverslip. For the U-ExM experiments, immunostaining of Histone H3 (Cell signaling, #9715) was performed using a 1/200 dilution followed with a 1/1000 diluted donkey anti-rabbit Alexa Fluor 488 secondary antibody (ThermoFisher, #A-21206). Antibodies were prepared in 3% PBS with 0.1% Tween 20.
Image analysis and quantifications
All images were analyzed using ImageJ (v1.52), and all figure panels were assembled with Adobe Illustrator CC 2020. Graphs were generated using either GraphPad (Prism 10) or ggplot2 in R (v4.0.5.). Statistics analyses were performed using internal functions of GraphPad (Prism 10), and all relevant information on statistics tests are reported in respective figures or legends. Decision to perform the exact statistics tests were made based on whether the data were normally distributed by a D’Agostino & Pearson normality test.
Fluorescence signal quantification and normalization against mitochondrial mass in fly embryos
Following protocol was employed for all the TMRE, JC9, CellROX and MitoPY1 signal quantifications. Images were pre-processed in ImageJ (v1.52) and were cropped to consistently sized stacks with the injected areas at their centers where the fluorescent signal was at its maximum. The mean intensity of each slice was measured using Measure function in ImageJ and averaged across the z-stack. To measure the background for each image, four equidistant slices across the stack were taken and manually traced within a region of interest (ROI) around His2Av- marked nuclei, or around the nuclear “shadows” that emerged due to backlighting of the cytoplasmic signal if there was no nuclear marker used. The mean background was subtracted from the mean signal within each embryo.
To normalize fluorescence intensities against the mitochondrial mass within each cell cycle, we calculated the mean fluorescence signal of mitochondria in embryos transgenically expressing Tom20 fused to a fluorescent protein (GFP or mCherry), where all the probe injection experiments were performed. The background for these images were also calculated as described above. The probe signals were then normalized based on the calculated mitochondrial mass within each cell cycle. As the MitoPY1 and CellROX double injections (with MitoTEMPO, S1QEL1.1 and S3QEL2) were not performed in embryos expressing a mitochondrial marker, we used the normalization standards calculated from the TMRE solo injection experiments.
For ONOO- dye signal quantifications, the above protocol was largely followed, except that the background was calculated via the far-red channel in unperturbed His2-GFP embryos. As ONOO- signal was not mitochondrial (Extended Data Fig. 7b), mitochondrial mass normalization was not applied.
Signal co-localization analyses
Whether signal foci from fluorescent probes co-localize with the mitochondrial signal was assessed manually. Aggregates of fluorescent foci were identified, and their position was compared to the position of mitochondria. If majority of the aggregation had an overlap with a mitochondrion, the aggregate was counted as localized to the mitochondria. If most of the aggregates did not overlap or had no overlap with any mitochondria, they were counted as not localizing to the mitochondria.
Quantification of mitochondrial dynamics and morphology in fly embryos
Percentage occurrence of mitochondrial fission and fusion dynamics were quantified in live embryos expressing V37-Gal4>UAS-Tom20-mCherry. Based on a common rule across many cell types that individual mitochondria go through alternating fission-fusion cycles120, an initial assessment revealed that mitochondria in early fly embryos also follow this pattern with an approximate period of 80-160s per fission-to-fusion cycle or vice versa (during the 12th nuclear division cycle). Taking the entire duration of nuclear cycle 12 into account (720-900s), the behavior of individual mitochondria was manually examined for 5 or 6 time points (with 120s intervals) across the cell cycle. The behavior of randomly chosen mitochondria were assessed at each time point until detecting five mitochondria that either fused or underwent fission, as not all mitochondria displayed membrane dynamics within our ±120s intervals (see Extended Data Fig. 1b, where ∼50% of the mitochondria are dynamic). Thus, on average, a total of ∼10 mitochondria were assessed for each time point per embryo. A constitutive separation or unity of mitochondria affirmed the behavior of fission or fusion respectively (see Fig. 1c). Temporal references on different phases of the cell cycle were determined by the exclusion of cytoplasmic fluorescent signal from the nucleoplasm (marking interphase), to which the signal would flood in when the nuclear envelope breaks (mitotic entry), and vice versa, when it reforms (mitotic exit).
Upon examination of their dynamics, the same mitochondria were utilized for size measurements, using the Line function in ImageJ. As most mitochondria are relatively small and positioned straight in the blastoderm (Fig. 1c), a line was drawn from one end to the next for each mitochondrion to manually measure their sizes.
Guidelines on assessing mitochondrial dynamics and autophagy in electron micrographs
To assess EM snapshots of mitochondrial membrane dynamics and motility, as well as of autophagy, previous guidelines were directly followed121–125. Briefly, mitochondrial fusion was judged by the connection of two mitochondria “bulges” where cristae structures are positioned orthogonally with respect, or unparallel, to each other. Mitochondrial fission was judged by pinching of a mitochondrion where the two pinched bulges appeared to have a unidirectional, continuous cristae structure. Mitochondrial motility was inferred from bent or curved mitochondria. Existence of autophagosomes was judged by membranous structures engulfing large vesicles or other organelles. Autolysosomes were evident by the former description along with a filling of undigested lipids.
Phenotypic classification and quantitation of various karyotypes
In embryos transgenically expressing His2Av fused to a fluorescent protein (GFP, RFP or CFP), the karyotypes observed upon a variety of perturbations in this study were classified into several groups based on the following criteria: Normal, when nuclei were like their counterparts during interphase or mitosis in unperturbed wild-type embryos. Telophase defects, when nuclei were arrested at a stage when their wild-type counterparts would be in telophase. Chromosome damages, when condensed chromosomes appeared broken and/or unevenly positioned in mitotic nuclei. The occasional nuclear fallouts observed during catalase injection experiments were classified as chromosome damages per prior literature126. Desiccated, when interphase nuclei appeared shrunken like peanuts, with sizes considerably smaller than expected average. Rabl-like, when chromosomes were condensed and lined against the inner wall of the nuclear envelope with all centromeres and telomeres at opposite poles of the nuclei – as described previously3. Stippled chromatin, when chromatin appeared in discrete conglomerates/speckles, but differently from Rabl-like, without an organized dispersal along the nuclear envelope. Nuclear clumping, when two or more nuclei were conjoined by their envelopes as though their centrosomes failed to separate. Chromatin dispersal along NE, when condensed chromosomes were lined-up against the inner wall of the nuclear envelope (NE) just as the Rabl-like phenotype, yet without a clear organization of the ends of chromosomes unlike it. This phenotype appeared to be a mixture of stippled chromatin and nuclear clumping phenotypes, as it displayed the features of both simultaneously. Swollen and oblong, when interphase nuclei appeared unusually large and/or in a non-round fashion. Mitotic catastrophe126, when mitotic chromatin appeared unusually disorganized in embryos attempting to cycle. Firework, when a portion of chromosomes were spread outward in a manner resembling this shape.
Care was taken to assign any observed phenotype – without omissions – into above classifications upon a variety of perturbations in this study. In each perturbed embryo, one of the above karyotype classes was observed as the defining phenotype (usually representing >80% of the nuclei in the blastoderm). Embryos were omitted from analysis only when they appeared a) sick, b) with sparse and uneven cytoplasm due to a harsh injection, c) with nuclei displaying high levels of karyotypic pleiotropy per the above classifications, or d) with a karyotype that failed to occur at a frequency that represent a statistically significant class per the above guidelines.
Quantifications of arrested D. rerio embryos
Zebrafish embryos injected with DMSO and MitoTEMPO were categorized into three time frames based on their survival into hours post-fertilization (hpf): 2-3, 3-4, and 4-5hpf. The embryos arrested in a particular time frame were not re-counted in the next time frame. The percentage of the ratio of surviving embryos were quantified and plotted.
Quantifications of nuclear content and division times in S. arctica cultures
For nuclear content distribution, the number of nuclei in fixed and Hoechst-stained S. arctica were counted using ObjectJ plugin in ImageJ. To compute nuclear division times, log2 of the geometric mean of the nuclear content was calculated as: log2(geommean) = ∑i fi ∗ log2(Xi) where fi is the fraction of coenocytes and xi the nuclear content (number of nuclei per cell) of each ith nuclear content bin. All experiments were performed for a minimum of three independent times.
Extended Data Figures
Supplementary Videos
Supplementary Video 1: Mitochondrial dynamics during blastoderm formation in flies expressing Tom20-mCherry.
Supplementary Video 2: mtROS depletion-triggered suspended animation in fly embryos (first half) with ‘no rescue’ phenotype upon H2O2 supplementation (4.9×10-10 M).
Supplementary Video 3: mtROS depletion-triggered suspended animation in fly embryos (first half) with ‘full rescue’ phenotype upon H2O2 supplementation (4.9×10-10 M).
Supplementary Video 4: mtROS depletion-triggered suspended animation in fly embryos (first half) with ‘partial rescue’ phenotype upon H2O2 supplementation (9.8×10-10 M).
Supplementary Video 5: mtROS depletion-triggered suspended animation in early zebrafish embryos.
Supplementary Video 6: mtROS depletion-triggered suspended animation in Sphaeroforma arctica.
Acknowledgements
We thank Profs. Bruce Alberts and Shelagh Campbell, as well as members of the Aydogan Laboratory, for their support, insightful discussions, and critical read of this manuscript. To the benefit of humankind, yet to the curse of the authors, the field of redox metabolism is vast, and so is developmental biology: we apologize for any unintended omissions of bibliography, or those that we could not have meaningfully discussed due to space limitations. The research was funded by NIH DP2GM154328 (M.G.A.), NIH P30DK098722 UCSF NORC P&F Award (M.G.A.), Sandler Foundation Investigator Award (7029760; M.G.A.), and New Frontier Research Award by UCSF Program for Breakthrough Biomedical Research (7031159; M.G.A.). L-E.J. was supported by NIH R01GM144435. M.O. and O.D. were supported by a Swiss National Science Foundation Starting Grant (TMSGI3 218007).
References
- 1.↵
- 2.↵
- 3.↵
- 4.↵
- 5.↵
- 6.↵
- 7.↵
- 8.↵
- 9.↵
- 10.↵
- 11.↵
- 12.↵
- 13.↵
- 14.↵
- 15.↵
- 16.↵
- 17.↵
- 18.↵
- 19.↵
- 20.↵
- 21.↵
- 22.↵
- 23.↵
- 24.↵
- 25.↵
- 26.↵
- 27.
- 28.
- 29.↵
- 30.↵
- 31.↵
- 32.↵
- 33.↵
- 34.↵
- 35.↵
- 36.↵
- 37.
- 38.↵
- 39.↵
- 40.↵
- 41.↵
- 42.↵
- 43.↵
- 44.↵
- 45.↵
- 46.↵
- 47.↵
- 48.↵
- 49.↵
- 50.↵
- 51.
- 52.
- 53.↵
- 54.↵
- 55.↵
- 56.↵
- 57.
- 58.↵
- 59.↵
- 60.↵
- 61.↵
- 62.↵
- 63.↵
- 64.↵
- 65.↵
- 66.↵
- 67.↵
- 68.
- 69.↵
- 70.↵
- 71.↵
- 72.↵
- 73.↵
- 74.
- 75.↵
- 76.↵
- 77.
- 78.
- 79.↵
- 80.
- 81.↵
- 82.
- 83.↵
- 84.
- 85.↵
- 86.↵
- 87.↵
- 88.↵
- 89.↵
- 90.↵
- 91.↵
- 92.↵
- 93.↵
- 94.↵
- 95.↵
- 96.↵
- 97.↵
- 98.↵
- 99.↵
- 100.↵
- 101.↵
- 102.↵
- 103.↵
- 104.↵
- 105.↵
- 106.↵
- 107.↵
- 108.↵