Specific domains of early parenting, their heritability and differential association with adolescent behavioural and emotional disorders and academic achievement

Background Variations in parenting across large populations have rarely been described. It also remains unclear which specific domains of parenting are important for which specific offspring developmental outcomes. The study describes different domains of early parenting behaviours, their genetic heritability, and then determines the extent to which specific domains of parenting are associated with later offspring outcomes.

Methods Parenting behaviours (birth to 3 years) were extracted from self-reported questionnaires administered to 12,358 mothers from the UK-based birth cohort study, the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children, and modelled as a latent factor using Confirmatory Factor Analysis. Genetic heritability and correlations between parenting factors were estimated using wide complex trait analysis. Offspring emotional, behavioural and academic outcomes were assessed at age 16 years using the self-reported Short Mood and Feelings Questionnaire, the Development and Well-Being Assessment, and grades achieved in national English Language examination.

Results Three parenting factors were derived: parental enjoyment, conflictual relationships and stimulation; all showed low genetic heritability. There was no evidence of associations between parenting factors and offspring depressed mood. Stimulation was associated with better English grades after controlling for maternal education (standardised β=0.058, p=0.007), and enjoyment was negatively associated with English grades (β=-0.082, p=0.002). Conflictual relationships were associated with higher risk of offspring behavioural disorders after controlling for behavioural problems at age 3 years (β=0.227, p=0.007). Higher enjoyment reduced the association between conflict and behavioural problems (interaction term β=0.113, p<0.001).

Conclusions We found evidence for predictive specificity of early parenting domains for offspring outcomes in adolescence. Early stimulation, unlike enjoyment, promoted later educational achievement. Conflictual relationships were associated with greater risk of behavioural problems, buffered by increased enjoyment. These findings hold implications for parenting interventions, guiding their focus according to specificity of parenting domains and their long-term outcomes in children.