Abstract
Background Mendelian randomization (MR) provides unconfounded estimates. MR is open to selection bias particularly when the underlying sample is selected on surviving the genetically instrumented exposure and other conditions that share etiology with the outcome (competing risk before recruitment). Few methods to address this bias exist.
Methods We use directed acyclic graphs to show this selection bias can be addressed by adjusting for common causes of survival and outcome. We use multivariable MR to obtain a corrected MR estimate, specifically, the effect of statin use on ischemic stroke, because statins affect survival and stroke typically occurs later in life than ischemic heart disease so is open to competing risk.
Results In univariable MR the genetically instrumented effect of statin use on ischemic stroke was in a harmful direction in MEGASTROKE and the UK Biobank (odds ratio (OR) 1.33, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.80 to 2.20). In multivariable MR adjusted for major causes of survival and ischemic stroke, (blood pressure, body mass index and smoking initiation) the effect of statin use on stroke in the UK Biobank was as expected (OR 0.81, 95% CI 0.68 to 0.98) with a Q-statistic indicating absence of genetic pleiotropy or selection bias, but not in MEGASTROKE.
Conclusion MR studies concerning late onset chronic conditions with shared etiology based on samples recruited in later life need to be conceptualized within a mechanistic understanding, so as to any identify potential bias due to competing risk before recruitment, and to inform the analysis and interpretation.
Competing Interest Statement
The authors have declared no competing interest.
Footnotes
This version has been revised to include the use of multivariable MR to address selection bias due to inadvertently selecting survivors of the genetically instrumented exposure and competing risk of the outcome. This is just an incremental process of improvement.
