Regular ArticleProximate costs of fighting in male cichlid fish: the role of injuries and energy metabolism
Abstract
While much is known about the functional significance of strategic decisions in animal fighting, relatively little is understood about the mechanisms that underlie the making of those decisions. In mechanistic terms, strategic decisions, such as either escalating a fight or giving up, are made in relation to the proximate costs that opponents inflict (or can potentially inflict) upon one another. These costs include physical injury and also the physiological consequences of engaging in an energetically demanding activity. We studied the role of injury and energy metabolism during fights between male cichlid fish,Tilapia zillii. In relation to injuries incurred during fights, scale loss differed depending on whether the winner was smaller or larger than its opponent; smaller winners inflicted significantly more damage on their opponents than they received, whereas this difference was not apparent in those fights won by the larger fish. In relation to energy metabolism, escalated fighting resulted in a significant depletion of total sugar reserves in the muscle and the liver. It appears that the muscle energy reserves are respired anaerobically, as was evident from the accumulation of lactate in the muscle. Losers had significantly higher levels of muscle lactate than winners. Together, the injury data and the metabolic data suggest that escalated fighting is costly for both winners and losers, but especially so for losers. These data are discussed in relation to models of animal decision making and we conclude that the difference between opponents in the proximate costs incurred during fighting is likely to underlie the making of decisions such as continuing, giving up or escalating the fight.
References (0)
Cited by (200)
How it ends: A review of behavioral and psychological phenomena, physiological processes and neural circuits in the termination of aggression in other animals and anger in people
2024, Behavioural Brain ResearchMore is known about aggression initiation and persistence in other animals, and anger in people, than about their cessation. This review summarizes knowledge of relevant factors in aggression, mostly in vertebrates, and anger termination in people. The latency, probability and intensity of offensive aggression in mice is controlled by activity in a neuronal subpopulation in ventromedial hypothalamus [VMH]. This activity instantiates an aggressive state termed angriffsbereitschaft [“attack-readiness”]. Fighting in many species is broken into bouts with interbout breaks due to fatigue and/or signals from dorsal raphe to VMH. Eventually, losers decide durations and outcomes of fighting by transitioning to submission or flight. Factors reducing angriffsbereitschaft and triggering these defeat behaviors could include metabolic costs, e.g., lactate accumulation and glucose depletion detected by the hypothalamus, central fatigue perhaps sensed by the Salience Network [insula and anterior cingulate gyrus] and pain of injuries, the latter insufficiently blunted by opioid and non-opioid stress analgesia and transduced by anterior VMH neurons. Winners’ angriffsbereitschaft continue for awhile, as indicated by post-victory attacks and, perhaps, triumph displays of some species, including humans. In longer term situations, sensory and/or response habituation of aggression may explain the “Dear enemy” tolerance of competitive neighbors. Prolonged satiation of predatory behavior could involve habenula-regulated reduction of dopaminergic reward in nucleus accumbens. Termination of human anger involves at least three processes, metaphorically termed decay, quenching and catharsis. Hypothesized neural mechanisms include anger diminution by negative feedback from accumbens to anterior cingulate and/or activity in the Salience Network that controls anger’s “accumulation/offset” phase.
Rise and fall: increasing temperatures have nonlinear effects on aggression in a tropical fish
2024, Animal BehaviourEnvironmental conditions are fundamental drivers of animal behaviour. Aggression in ectotherms is a marked example and is often considered positively correlated with temperature. However, many studies exploring this relationship, and its important consequences, focus on a few temperatures and implicitly assume a linear relationship between the two variables. This may limit our understanding of the influence of temperature on aggression. We measured levels of aggression in Neolamprologus pulcher, a cichlid fish commonly used as a model in studies of aggression-based social hierarchy, across a range of temperatures in a mirror aggression test. We used temperatures expected from their natural range with a 2 °C extension on either end. As predicted by thermal performance curves, rates of aggression increased with temperature at the lower end of the temperature range. After reaching a peak, any further increase in temperature resulted in a considerable drop in rates of aggression. Exploring responses at a finer temporal scale, we found that the influence of high temperatures changed dramatically during the 25 min trials. Early in the trials the frequency of aggression increased linearly with temperature, across all temperatures. The initially high levels of aggression at the higher temperatures were not sustained and dropped with increasing duration of exposure to the mirror at high temperatures. Together these findings provide a more comprehensive understanding of the influence of short-term exposure to different temperatures on aggression, such as acute exposure to increased temperatures caused by global warming and associated rapid thermal fluctuations, in African rift lake fishes and in ectotherms more generally. Moreover, our results highlight the importance of measuring aggression across a range of temperatures or otherwise account for nonlinear changes in thermal performance.
Non-angry aggressive arousal and angriffsberietschaft: A narrative review of the phenomenology and physiology of proactive/offensive aggression motivation and escalation in people and other animals
2023, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral ReviewsHuman aggression typologies largely correspond with those for other animals. While there may be no non-human equivalent of angry reactive aggression, we propose that human proactive aggression is similar to offense in other animals’ dominance contests for territory or social status. Like predation/hunting, but unlike defense, offense and proactive aggression are positively reinforcing, involving dopamine release in accumbens. The drive these motivational states provide must suffice to overcome fear associated with initiating risky fights. We term the neural activity motivating proactive aggression “non-angry aggressive arousal”, but use “angriffsberietschaft” for offense motivation in other animals to acknowledge possible differences. Temporal variation in angriffsberietschaft partitions fights into bouts; engendering reduced anti-predator vigilance, redirected aggression and motivational over-ride. Increased aggressive arousal drives threat-to-attack transitions, as in verbal-to-physical escalation and beyond that, into hyper-aggression. Proactive aggression and offense involve related neural activity states. Cingulate, insular and prefrontal cortices energize/modulate aggression through a subcortical core containing subnuclei for each aggression type. These proposals will deepen understanding of aggression across taxa, guiding prevention/intervention for human violence.
I love to hate my neighbour: how recognition of dear enemies affects male antipredator behaviours in a lizard species
2023, Animal BehaviourIn species in which individuals defend territories for long periods, it is common that rivals in neighbouring territories learn to recognize each other or their territory boundaries and reduce their mutual aggressiveness to decrease the costs of territorial defence (‘dear enemy’ phenomenon). Although the dear enemy phenomenon is generally evaluated in terms of aggressive behaviours between rivals, the ability to recognize neighbours (‘dear enemy recognition’) may affect other behaviours. In particular, antipredator behaviours may be mediated by the status of rivals (familiar neighbours or unfamiliar intruders) because individuals may be more resistant to escape from predators if the nearby rivals are unfamiliar intruders than familiar neighbours that have not historically infringed on their territory. In this scenario, the ability to recognize familiar neighbours would affect an individual's escape decisions. Here, we evaluated the hypothesis that resident males of the lizard Eurolophosaurus nanuzae adopt lower-risk antipredator behaviours after encountering a familiar neighbour than after encountering an unfamiliar intruder. For this, we measured lizards' flight initiation distance and time spent in a refuge under three conditions: after no recent contact with other males, after previous exposure to a familiar neighbour and after previous exposure to an unfamiliar intruder. We observed lower flight initiation distances for males that had encountered an unfamiliar intruder compared to a familiar neighbour, and we observed the greatest flight initiation distances when the same lizards had no recent contact with other individuals (familiar neighbours or unfamiliar intruders). As expected, lizards that had no contact with rivals spent more time hidden compared to lizards in the other treatments, but the time spent hidden was similar when lizards were exposed to a familiar neighbour or an unfamiliar intruder. These results indicate the existence of an important cognitive mechanism that allows individuals to recognize rivals along with their interaction history and modulate their initial escape strategy accordingly.
‘Hangry’ Drosophila: food deprivation increases male aggression
2021, Animal BehaviourAggressive interactions are costly, such that individuals should display modified aggression in response to environmental stress. Many organisms experience frequent periods of food deprivation, which can influence an individual's capacity and motivation to engage in aggression. However, because food deprivation can simultaneously decrease an individual's resource-holding potential and increase its valuation of food resources, its net impact on aggression is unclear. Here, we tested the influence of increasingly prolonged periods of adult food deprivation on intermale aggression in pairs of fruit flies, Drosophila melanogaster. We found that males displayed increased aggression following periods of food deprivation longer than a day. Increased aggression in food-deprived flies occurred despite their reduced mass. This result is probably explained by an increased attraction to food resources, as food deprivation increased male occupancy of central food patches, and food patch occupancy was positively associated with aggression. Our findings demonstrate that aggressive strategies in male D. melanogaster are influenced by nutritional experience, highlighting the need to consider past nutritional stresses to understand variation in aggression.
Parental male and female convict cichlids assess and respond to threats differently depending on intruder species
2021, Behavioural ProcessesIn this field experiment, we presented pairs of monogamous convict cichlids with different intruders (conspecific and either cichlid or non-cichlid heterospecific) and observed the aggressive behavior of the pair to determine if pairs adjust aggression based upon species of intruder. We predicted that pairs would be more aggressive to conspecifics as these intruders represent multiple threats. The overall pair aggression was significantly higher to the conspecific intruder than to either heterospecific intruder. We also predicted that within pairs, the sexes might differ in how they assessed the risk represented by the intruders and might respond differently. Indeed, females were significantly more aggressive to the conspecific than to either heterospecific whereas males were more aggressive to the conspecific only compared to the non-cichlid heterospecific. These results suggest parental convict cichlids differently assess the risk posed by an intruder and then adjust aggression to different species of intruder. It also supports that the aggressive roles within a pair are flexible and that males and females modulate their behavior differently in response to different species of intruders perhaps based on differences in risk assessment.