Abstract
The paper argues for a pragmatic account of genetic explanation. This is to say that when a disease or other trait is termed ‘genetic,’ the reasons for singling out genes as causes over other, also necessary, genetic and nongenetic conditions are not wholly theoretical but include pragmatic dimensions. Whether the explanation is the presence of a trait in an individual or differences in a trait among individuals, genetic explanations are context-dependent in three ways: they are relative to a causal background of genetic and nongenetic factors; they are relative to a population; and they are relative to the present state of knowledge. Criteria like causal priority, nonstandardness, and causal efficacy that purport to distinguish objectively between genetic causes and nongenetic conditions either incorporate pragmatic elements or fail for other reasons. When the pragmatic dimensions of genetic explanations are recognized, we come to understand the current phenomenon of “geneticization” to be a reflection of increased technological capacities to manipulate genes in the laboratory, and potentially the clinic, rather than theoretical progress in understanding how diseases and other traits arise. This calls into question the value of the search for theoretical definitions of designations like ‘genetic disease’ or ‘genetic susceptibility’ as directives for action.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Baird, P.A.: 1990, ‘Genetics and Health Care: A Paradigm Shift’, Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 33, 203-213.
Bodmer, Walter and McKie, Robin: 1994, The Book of Man: The Quest to Discover Our Genetic Heritage, Viking Press, Toronto.
Collingwood, R.G.: 1938, ‘On the So-Called Idea of Causation’, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 85-112.
Dawkins, Richard: 1982, The Extended Phenotype: The Long Reach of the Gene, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Duster, Troy: 1990, Backdoor to Eugenics, Routledge, New York.
Edlin, Gordon J.: 1987, ‘Inappropriate Use of Genetic Terminology in Medical Research: A Public Health Issue’, Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 31, 47-56.
Gifford, Fred: 1990, ‘Genetic Traits’, Biology and Philosophy 5, 327-347.
Gilbert, Walter: 1992, ‘A Vision of the Grail’, in Kevles, Daniel J. and Hood, Leroy (eds.), The Code of Codes: Scientific and Social Issues in the Human Genome Project, Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA, pp. 83-97.
Hesslow, Germund: 1983, ‘Explaining and Weighing Causes’, Theoria 49, 87-111.
Hesslow, Germund: 1984, ‘What is a Genetic Disease?: On the Relative Importance of Causes’, in Nordenfelt, Lennart and Lindahl, B. Ingemar B. (eds.), Health, Disease, and Causal Explanations in Medicine, D. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 183-193.
Kaplan, Abraham: 1965, ‘Noncausal Explanation’, in Lerner, Daniel (ed.), Cause and Effect: The Hayden Colloquium on Scientific Method and Concept, The Free Press, New York, pp. 145-155.
Kearsey, Michael J. and Pooni, Harpal S.: 1996, The Genetical Analysis of Quantitative Traits, Chapman and Hill, London.
Keller, Evelyn Fox: 1994, ‘Master Molecules’, in Cranor, Carl F. (ed.), Are Genes Us? The Social Consequences of the New Genetics, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick NJ, pp. 89-98.
Keller, Evelyn Fox: 1995, Refiguring Life: Metaphors of Twentieth-Century Biology, Columbia University Press, New York.
Kevles, Daniel J.: 1995, In the Name of Eugenics: Genetics and the Uses of Human Heredity, Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA.
Kitcher, Philip: 1996, The Lives to Come: The Genetic Revolution and Human Possibilities, Simon & Schuster, New York.
Lewontin, R.C.: 1974, ‘The Analysis of Variance and the Analysis of Causes’, American Journal of Human Genetics 26, 400-411.
Lewontin, R.C.: 1993, The Doctrine of DNA: Biology as Ideology, Penguin Books, London.
Lipmann, Abby: 1991, ‘Prenatal Genetic Testing and Screening: Constructing Needs and Reinforcing Inequities’, American Journal of Law and Medicine 62, 15-50.
Mackie, J.L.: 1965, ‘Causes and Conditions’, American Philosophical Quarterly 2, 245-264.
Mackie, J.L.: 1980, The Cement of the Universe: A Study of Causation, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Mayr, Ernst: 1961, ‘Cause and Effect in Biology’, Science 134, 1501-1506.
Nordenfelt, Lennart: 1981, Causation: An Essay, Forlaget Akademilitteratur, Stockholm.
Plomin, Robert and Hershberger, Scott: 1991, ‘Genotype-Environment Interaction’, in Wachs, Theodore D. and Plomin, Robert (eds.), Conceptualization and Measurement of Organism-Environment Interaction, American Psychological Association, Washington DC, pp. 29-43.
Salmon, Wesley C.: 1984, Scientific Explanation and the Causal Structure of the World, Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ.
Sarkar, Sahotra: 1996, ‘Biological Information: A Skeptical Look at Some Central Dogmas of Molecular Biology’, in Sarkar, Sahotra (ed.), The Philosophy and History of Molecular Biology: New Perspectives, Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 187-231.
Smith, Kelly C.: 1992, ‘The New Problem of Genetics: A Response to Gifford’, Biology and Philosophy 7, 331-348.
Sober, Elliott: 1984, The Nature of Selection, MIT Press, Cambridge MA.
Sterelny, Kim and Kitcher, Philip: 1988, ‘The Return of the Gene’, The Journal of Philosophy 85, 339-361.
Strohman, Richard C.: 1993, ‘Ancient Genomes, Wise Bodies, Unhealthy People: Limits of a Genetic Paradigm in Biology and Medicine’, Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 37, 112-145.
Suppes, Patrick: 1970, A Probabilistic Theory of Causation, North Holland, Amsterdam.
van Fraassen, Bas: 1980, The Scientific Image, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Wachs, Theodore D.: 1991, ‘Synthesis: Promising Research Designs, Measures, and Strategies’, in Wachs, Theodore D. and Plomin, Robert (eds.), Conceptualization and Measurement of Organism-Environment Interaction, American Psychological Association, Washington DC, pp. 162-182.
Watson, James D.: 1992, ‘A Personal View of the Project’, in Kevles, Daniel J. and Hood, Leroy (eds.), The Code of Codes: Scientific and Social Issues in the Human Genome Project, Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA, pp. 164-173.
Weatherall, David: 1994, ‘The Relative Roles of Nature and Nature in Common Disease’, in Cartledge, Bryan (ed.), Health and the Environment: The Linacre Lectures 1992–3, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 172-198.
Wulff, Henrik R.: 1984, ‘Comments on Hesslow's ‘What is a Genetic Disease?’ ’, in Nordenfelt, Lennart and Lindahl, B. Ingemar B. (eds.), Health, Disease, and Causal Explanations in Medicine, D. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 195-197.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gannett, L. What's in a Cause?: The Pragmatic Dimensions of Genetic Explanations. Biology & Philosophy 14, 349–373 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006583215835
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006583215835