In the aging heart, decreased rates of calcium transport mediated by the SERCA2a isoform of the sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) Ca-ATPase are responsible for the slower sequestration of cytosolic calcium and consequent prolonged muscle relaxation times. We report a 60% decrease in Ca-ATPase activity in the senescent Fischer 344 rat heart relative to that of young adult hearts; this functional decrease can be attributed, in part, to the 18% lower abundance of SERCA2a protein. Here, we show that the additional loss of activity is a result of increased 3-nitrotyrosine modification of the Ca-ATPase. Age-dependent increases in nitration of cardiac SERCA2a are identified using multiple analytical methods. In the young (adult) heart 1 molar equivalent of nitrotyrosine is distributed over at least five tyrosines within the Ca-ATPase, identified as Tyr(122), Tyr(130), Tyr(497), Tyr(586), and Tyr(990). In the senescent heart, the stoichiometry of nitration increases by more than two nitrotyrosines per Ca-ATPase, coinciding with the appearance of nitrated Tyr(294), Tyr(295), and Tyr(753). The abundant recovery of native analogues for each of the nitrated peptides indicates partial modification of multiple tyrosines within cardiac SERCA2a. In contrast, within skeletal muscle SERCA2a, a homogeneous pattern of nitration appears, with full site (1 mol/mol) nitration of Tyr(753), in young, with additional nitration of Tyr(294) and Tyr(295), in senescent muscle. The nitration of these latter vicinal sites correlates with diminished transport function in both striated muscle types, suggesting that these sites provide a mechanism for downregulation of ATP utilization by the Ca-ATPase under conditions of nitrative stress.