As a posttranslational protein modification, cysteine sulfenic acid (Cys-SOH) is well established as an oxidative stress-induced mediator of enzyme function and redox signaling. Data presented herein show that protein Cys-SOH forms spontaneously in air-exposed aqueous solutions of unfolded (disulfide-reduced) protein in the absence of added oxidizing reagents, mediating the oxidative disulfide bond formation process key to in vitro, nonenzymatic protein folding. Molecular oxygen (O(2)) and trace metals [e.g., copper(II)] are shown to be important reagents in the oxidative refolding process. Cys-SOH is also shown to play a role in spontaneous disulfide-based dimerization of peptide molecules containing free cysteine residues. In total, the data presented expose a chemically ubiquitous role for Cys-SOH in solutions of free cysteine-containing protein exposed to air.