Human catechol-O-methyltransferase (COMT) catalyzes a methyl transfer from S-adenosylmethionine (AdoMet) to dopamine. Site-specific mutants at three positions (Tyr68, Trp38, and Val108) have been characterized with regard to product distribution, catalytic efficiency, and secondary kinetic isotope effects. The series of mutations at Tyr68 within wild-type protein and the common polymorphic variant (Val108Met) yields a linear correlation between the catalytic efficiency and the size of the secondary kinetic isotope effect. We conclude that active site compaction in COMT is modulated by a proximal side chain residing behind the sulfur-bearing methyl group of AdoMet. These findings are discussed in the context of the active site compression that has been postulated to accompany enzyme-supported hydrogen tunneling.